|
VIEWPOINT
|
THE CONSUMERS UNION PERSPECTIVE |
|
| Here, a monthly perspective from Consumers Union on the latest challenges—and possible solutions—facing U.S. consumers today.
See archived letters. |
|
Emergency rooms need urgent care
The nation’s emergency rooms are facing their own crisis.
The Institute of Medicine, a prestigious health-science group, issued a three-volume report in June 2006 titled “The Future
of Emergency Care.” It’s grim reading. Between 1993 and 2003, visits to emergency rooms increased from 90.3 million to 113.9
million. Over the same 10 years, 425 ERs were shut down. It’s no wonder that those that are left are jammed, leading to extremely
long waits and patients parked on gurneys in hallways waiting for a bed.
The institute also found that, on average, every minute of every day an ambulance somewhere in the U.S. is “on diversion,”
meaning it’s sent to a more distant hospital because the closest one is too crowded or too busy. That delay can mean the difference
between life and death for stroke, heart attack, or bleeding victims.
Worthy IdeasCongress is showing an interest in fixing the problem, and Consumers Union strongly supports legislative action. The institute’s
proposals are common sense and would be cost-effective to put in place. Among them:
- Create better regional coordination and communication to direct ambulances to ERs with enough capacity and the right specialists
on duty.
- Ensure that all new or remodeled hospitals use “best practices” in designing their emergency rooms.
- Equip ERs with readily accessible X-ray and MRI machines to cut down on delayed diagnoses.
Some ER service problems are an outgrowth of our health-care system. Many Americans with no health insurance use emergency
rooms as their primary source of treatment. The uninsured crowd into ERs hoping to get care that they can’t get, or can’t
afford, anywhere else.
The report also recognizes that emergency rooms are the only place most people, insured or not, can go at night or on weekends.
Unlike some European countries, the U.S. doesn’t have a reliable system of after-hours care. To take the strain off emergency
rooms, we need medical facilities where patients can get treatment during off-hours. That will be a longer, tougher fix and
depends on the involvement of community health clinics and flexible medical practices willing to provide after-hours care.
Many of you have written to Consumers Union to tell us about your ER experiences. We’ve heard the good and the bad: dedicated
and hardworking staff members who toil in a system that can be dysfunctional, the endless waits, the failure to treat excruciating
pain, poor-quality care, sky-high costs, and even preventable death.
From your stories and the report, it is clear we need a way to measure ER quality more comprehensibly so that the public and
policymakers can quantify differences. Publicly rating ambulance services and ERs for wait times and for differences in care
among racial and ethnic groups will push hospitals to put more effort into this first line of critical health care.