Consumer Reports Video  |
| SAFETY ALERT |
 |
Important autos safety features View video  |
 |
Don't overlook safety features when comparing different models. Antilock brakes and electronic stability control, for instance,
are effective and well worth the money. Remember, though, that the most important thing you can do to protect your life is
to buckle your seatbelt. Safety belts save lives on their own, but many of the more advanced safety features, such as seatbelt
pretensioners and air bags, only work best for people who are buckled up to start with.
Here's a rundown of some of the more important safety gear.
Air bags | Antilock brakes (ABS) | Brake assist | Traction control
Safety-belt features | Electronic stability control | LATCH (Lower Anchors and Tethers for Children)
Tire-pressure monitor | Telematics
Air bags (back to top)
Front air bags are now standard on all new vehicles. Crash sensors connected to an onboard computer detect a frontal collision
and trigger the bags. The bags inflate in a few milliseconds--the blink of an eye--then immediately start deflating.
While air bags have saved thousands of lives, they also have the potential to cause injury or even death, especially to children
or to occupants who aren't using a seatbelt. Children under 12 should be seated in the rear in an appropriate restraint system.
Since 1997, automakers have reduced the bags' deployment force and have developed new control systems that respond more appropriately
to crash severity.
A new generation of adaptive, or dual-stage front air bags is standard on many current cars. Most of these adaptive systems
can detect whether or not the seat belt is fastened, as well as the severity of a crash. In a low-level collision, the system
inflates the front air bags less aggressively--with 70 to 80 percent of the force of a single-stage air bag. In a higher-speed
collision they inflate with full force, providing firmer protection. Better air-bag systems such as those offered in some
Acura, BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and GM models (among others) use sensors that detect the presence and weight of the person in the
passenger seat and deactivate or adjust the deployment of the air bag accordingly. The best air-bag systems can detect the
presence, height, and seat position for the driver and front passenger, and deactivate or de-power front air bags as appropriate
to minimize the chance of injury to out-of-position occupants or children.
Side-impact air bags for front-seat passengers are becoming more common and affordable, and some automakers are now offering
side bags for rear-seat passengers as well. When they first arrived, side air bags were fairly small cushions that popped
out of the door trim or the side of the seatback. They helped protect the torso, but weren't as effective in protecting the
head. Now, more and more models use additional head-protection air bags that usually deploy downward from above the side windows.
Side-curtain bags, the most common type, spread across both front and rear side windows to prevent occupants from hitting
their heads and to shield them from flying debris. A curtain bag can also keep people from being ejected during a rollover.
The better head-protection systems deploy the side-curtain bags if the system detects that the vehicle is beginning to roll
over. (For more information on crash testing and Ratings, see our Crash test 101 report).
Antilock brakes (ABS) (back to top)
Before antilock brakes came along, it was all too easy to lock up the wheels (stop them turning) during hard braking, particularly
on slippery surfaces. When the wheels lock up, the vehicle tends to keep plowing ahead in whatever direction it was going.
You can't steer, and locked wheels can cause a vehicle to slide sideways. ABS prevents this from happening. Antilock brakes
use wheel-speed sensors at each wheel and a computer that coordinates the braking action, rapidly pulsing the brakes on and
off when you hit the pedal hard. By preventing lock-up, ABS allows the driver to retain steering control while braking, so
that the car can be maneuvered around an obstacle, if necessary.
Brake assist (back to top)
Mercedes-Benz pioneered this adjunct to ABS. By sensing the speed or force with which the brake pedal is depressed, it determines
if the driver wants to make an emergency stop. If so, it makes sure the ABS is activated and boosts brake pressure. Brake
assist is available on some Audi, Lexus, Mercedes, Nissan, and Toyota vehicles, among others.
Traction control (back to top)
This electronically controlled system limits wheel spin during acceleration so that the drive wheels have maximum traction.
It's particularly useful when starting off in wet or icy conditions. Some traction-control systems operate only at low speeds,
while others work at all speeds.
Most low-speed traction-control systems use the car's antilock brake system. If the system detects wheelspin while accelerating
on a slippery surface, it momentarily applies the brakes to the slipping wheel. This stops the slipping and automatically
routes power to the opposite drive wheel. All-speed traction control uses a combination of ABS and powertrain control. In
slick conditions and at higher speeds, a system of sensors and computers may upshift the transmission, throttle back the engine,
and apply the brakes--or a combination of these--to prevent wheelspin.
Safety-belt features (back to top)
While the seatbelt is arguably the single most important piece of safety equipment, enhanced belt features are helping seatbelts
do their job more effectively.
Adjustable upper anchors for the shoulder belts can make a meaningful safety difference. Adjustable anchors help position
the belt across the chest instead of the neck to prevent neck injuries. They also can help keep the belt from pulling down
on a tall person's shoulder, making it more comfortable and encouraging its use.
Seatbelt pretensioners instantly retract the belts to take up slack during a frontal impact. This also helps position occupants
properly to take full advantage of a deploying airbag. Force limiters, a companion feature to pretensioners, manage the force
that the shoulder belt builds up on the occupant's chest. After the pretensioners tighten it, force limiters let the belt
pay back out a little.
LATCH (Lower Anchors and Tethers for Children) (back to top)
All vehicles are now required to have the LATCH system. The system features built-in lower anchors and top-tether attachment
points allowing LATCH-compatible child safety seats to be installed without using the vehicle's safety-belt system. The LATCH
system helps child-seat installation by reducing incompatibilities that safety-belt installation may present. But we've found
a number of cars and trucks whose LATCH system is tough to use correctly, so try before you buy a new child seat.
Electronic stability control (ESC) (back to top)
Electronic stability control takes electronic traction control a step further. This system helps keep the vehicle on its intended
path during a turn, to avoid sliding or skidding. It uses a computer linked to a series of sensors--detecting wheel speed,
steering angle, sideways motion and yaw (spin). If the car starts to drift, the stability-control system momentarily brakes
one or more wheels and, depending on the system, reduces engine power to keep the car back on course.
ESC is especially helpful in providing an extra measure of control in slippery conditions and accident-avoidance situations.
With tall, top-heavy vehicles like sport-utilities and pickups, it can also help keep a vehicle from getting into a situation
where it could roll over.
Ford and Volvo have taken stability control a step further with Roll Stability Control (RSC). It uses gyroscopic sensors to
determine roll angle and roll speed to determine if a rollover is imminent. If so, it triggers the standard stability control
system and instantly reduces power and brakes the necessary wheels to bring the vehicle back under control. This system is
found on the Volvo XC90, Ford Explorer, Expedition, and Lincoln Navigator SUVs among others.
General Motors and Chrysler have introduced competing rollover-mitigation systems. GM's is called Proactive Roll Avoidance
(PRA), and Chryslers is called Electronic Roll Mitigation (ERM). They are found on the 2007 and later Cadillac Escalade, Chevrolet
Tahoe and Suburban, GMC Yukon, Jeep Compass and Wrangler, among other vehicles.
Electronic stability control started on luxury cars and has been migrating to SUVs and many other vehicles. To confuse matters,
automakers each tend to have a proprietary name for their stability control systems (see the accompanying table). To help
consumers identify the system in a vehicle's features list, the Society of Automotive Engineers has asked that all manufacturers
use electronic stability control or ESC, as common terminology when referring to their stability-control systems. Consumer Reports supports this move because it will help consumers know what they are buying. If in doubt whether a car has it, find out before
you buy.
| |
|
|
DECIPHERING STABILITY CONTROL
|
|
| |
|
|
Stability control helps keep a vehicle from skidding sideways. Automakers give their systems a confusing array of names,
including the ones listed below: |
|
|
|
|
|
MAKE |
|
STABILITY-CONTROL SYSTEM NAME |
|
|
|
Acura |
|
Vehicle Stability Assist (VSA) |
|
|
|
Audi |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
BMW |
|
Dynamic Stability Control (DSC) |
|
|
|
Buick |
|
StabiliTrak |
|
|
|
Cadillac |
|
StabiliTrak |
|
|
|
Chevrolet |
|
Active Handling (cars); StabiliTrak (SUVs) |
|
|
|
Chrysler |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Dodge |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Ford |
|
AdvanceTrac |
|
|
|
GMC |
|
StabiliTrak |
|
|
|
Honda |
|
Vehicle Stability Assist (VSA) |
|
|
|
Hummer |
|
StabiliTrak |
|
|
|
Hyundai |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Infiniti |
|
Vehicle Dynamic Control (VDC) |
|
|
|
Jaguar |
|
Dynamic Stability Control (DSC) |
|
|
|
Jeep |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Kia |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Land Rover |
|
Dynamic Stability Control (DSC) |
|
|
|
Lexus |
|
Vehicle Stability Control (VSC) |
|
|
|
Lincoln |
|
AdvanceTrac |
|
|
|
Mazda |
|
Dynamic Stability Control (DSC) |
|
|
|
Mercedes-Benz |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Mercury |
|
AdvanceTrac |
|
|
|
Mini |
|
Dynamic Stability Control (DSC) |
|
|
|
Mitsubishi |
|
Mitsubishi Active Skid and Traction Control System (M-ASTC) |
|
|
|
Nissan |
|
Vehicle Dynamic Control (VDC) |
|
|
|
Pontiac |
|
StabiliTrak |
|
|
|
Porsche |
|
Porsche Stability Management (PSM) |
|
|
|
Saab |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Saturn |
|
StabiliTrak |
|
|
|
Scion |
|
Vehicle Stability Control (VSC) |
|
|
|
Subaru |
|
Vehicle Dynamics Control (VDC) |
|
|
|
Suzuki |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Toyota |
|
Vehicle Stability Control (VSC) |
|
|
|
Volkswagen |
|
Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
|
|
|
Volvo |
|
Dynamic Stability Traction Control (DSTC) |
|
| |
|
Consumer Reports' auto experts highly recommend stability control where it's offered. But it does have its limits: You can't just speed into
a curve and expect the system to bail you out. Taking any corner too fast could compromise the system's ability to keep the
vehicle on course.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has announced plans to
require ESC to be phased in as standard equipment by the 2012 model year.
Tire-pressure monitor (
back to top)
Underinflated tires can hurt handling and fuel economy, as well as cause premature wear--or a possible blowout--of the tire.
Yet a tire can lose air so slowly that many drivers don't realize it's happening. A government regulation requires all new
vehicles made after October 31, 2006 to have a low-tire-pressure warning system. The type of tire-pressure monitor we favor
measures tire pressure directly. A competing technology, and one the government has approved, gauges air loss indirectly by
using sensors to count wheel revolutions. We don't think those systems are sensitive enough. In any case, we suggest regularly
checking your tires with a conventional tire-pressure gauge.
Telematics (
back to top)
Combining cellular telephone and Global Positioning Satellite (GPS) technology, several major automakers are offering an automated
service that provides a high level of security and convenience. GM was the first with its OnStar service, followed later by
Mercedes-Benz's TeleAid, BMW Assist, Volvo OnCall, and Lexus Link. All use the same technology and offer basically the same
services. In operation, with the touch of a button the driver can communicate with a central dispatch center, where the location
of the vehicle can be tracked on a computer monitor to provide route directions or emergency aid. If a vehicle's air bag is
deployed in a collision, the system automatically notifies the dispatch center, locates the vehicle, and sends emergency aid
if the driver does not respond to an inquiry. A phone call to the dispatch center can find a "lost" car in a parking lot by
beeping the horn, or unlock the doors if the keys have been misplaced. OnStar is available on all GM cars and trucks, as well
as on Saab, Acura, Audi, and other makes. TeleAid is offered only on Mercedes-Benz models. Additional systems include BMW’s
Assist and Volvo’s Oncall. The cost of the system is built into the price of most vehicles, but a monthly service fee is usually
required.