Panasonic TH-42PX60U Panasonic TH-50PX60U

Panasonic models have topped our plasma TV Ratings (available to subscribers) over the past year and qualified as Quick Picks--select models we single out for both performance and value. The 2005 versions of those TVs, with model numbers that end in “50U,” are now very scarce in stores. But preliminary tests on two of their replacements, the 42-inch TH-42PX60U at $2,500 and the 50-inch TH-50PX60U at $3,500, suggest the 2006 Panasonics offer comparable performance and value, and even add a few worthwhile enhancements.

PROS

Overall picture quality. Last year, we singled out the 50U sets for superb picture quality. The 2006 models, dubbed 60U, appear to be superb performers as well, though our preliminary tests found a few minor image flaws (see Cons below). We were impressed with the sharp detail on the 42-inch TV, which has native resolution of 1024x768. The 50-inch model has 1366x768 native resolution, as is necessary to produce high-quality HD images on a larger screen. (In both cases, we judged the pictures from the recommended viewing distances for the set.)

More ways to connect. These new Panasonics have four HD-capable inputs: two component-video inputs and two HDMI inputs, one more than last year. The second HDMI input should be a plus as more devices--including high-definition DVD players--adopt this digital connection over the next few years. Also, the front panel now has audio/video inputs for easily connecting a digital camcorder and a slot for an SD memory card, which allows you to play videos or display photos by using the TV’s on-screen menus and remote control.

Easy-to-use controls. A redesigned universal remote control has sizable buttons and large print, enhancing usability. A new EZ-Sync control feature allows simplified control of other Panasonic components connected to the TV. The control buttons on the front of the set itself are bigger and easier to use.

Slimmed-down design. The speakers are mounted below the screen rather than on the side, trimming 5 or so inches off the width of the TV, compared with the Panasonics that have side-mounted speakers.

CONS

Minor display flaws. In our initial viewing tests, we detected a slight boost in image enhancement that we couldn’t correct by adjusting the settings. In plain English, images looked a little hyper-realistic to our experts, with hard edges and some exaggerated detail. But the effect is slight and might not be obvious to the typical viewer.

No CableCard slot--for the few people who really need one. Panasonic has eliminated the CableCard slot that was a feature on the 50U models, a step other manufacturers are taking as well. While that means you’ll need a cable box to get HD and premium channels, it’s no great loss. Since CableCards currently work in only one direction, you can’t use them anyway if you want interactive features such as a full-featured onscreen program guide and video on demand. If you do want CableCard capability, it is available on two higher-priced models in Panasonic’s new line, the TH-42PX600U, $3,200, and TH-50PX600U, $4,200; those models also have the TV Guide electronic program guide.

A few quibbles with controls. While the remote gets kudos for overall design, it’s not backlit, so it’s still hard to use in dim rooms. The onscreen menu makes you wade through more levels than we’d like, and the hard-to-read labeling on the rear-panel inputs makes connections challenging.

THE BOTTOM LINE

Based on preliminary testing, the Panasonic TH-42PX60U and TH-50PX60U look like strong performers. They have outstanding picture quality and more useful features than the 50U models they replace--and, with the continuing decline in flat-panel TV prices, they even cost less. But if you can still find the 2005 models, they’re worth considering, at the right price.