For complete access
Get full access to Ratings and recommendations on appliances, cars & trucks, electronic gear, and much more.  today to ConsumerReports.org.
July 2005
send to a friend printable version

Testing gloves for work

Work gloves with stretch nylon on sides of fingers and velcro straps on cuff.
Work gloves with padding on palm and fingertips.

POINTING FINGERS Useful features in work gloves:

1. Stretch nylon on sides of fingers.

2. Padding on palm and fingertips for extra protection.

3. Velcro straps on cuff.

Work gloves have gone modern, with new materials and designs that provide fit, flexibility, and versatility. Spandex and artificial leather yield gloves that can be washed without getting stiff; spandex also makes it possible to create a truly fitted glove. And, as our tests show, the new materials can work well.

All but the Tomboy Tools gloves are made from artificial leather, and most have some amount of spandex. Most come in at least three sizes, including extra extra large.

We asked 20 men and 7 women to use the gloves for their normal home- and auto-maintenance chores, carpentry, and heavy yard work, then tell us which were well-suited for the work and which they preferred for comfort and fit.

We had the panelists do specific tasks--thread a nut onto a bolt and flip the switch on a small power tool, for example--so we could gauge usefulness in detail work.

In general, lower-rated gloves have bulky seams inside the fingers, which made the gloves uncomfortable. They also tend to have extra padding, which panelists said got in the way. Panelists often said that the higher-rated gloves felt like a second skin.

The bottom line. Best overall: the Custom Leathercraft Handyman, a CR Best Buy at $10. Or consider the Mechanix Original and Mechanix Series 2.0. Gloves marketed for women are sized for smaller hands; but that's also true of the gender-neutral Mechanix and Ringers gloves.


 Brand & model

Price

Test results

Sizes

 


Text here

Text here

Text here

Text here

FOR MEN AND WOMEN

Custom Leathercraft Handyman CR Best Buy

$10  

Mechanix Original

25

Mechanix Series 2.0 High Dexterity

20

Ironclad Wrenchworx

26  

Ringers Authentic

25

Wells Lamont Talon Grips

19  

Ironclad WorkForce AT

23  

Craftsman (Sears) Professional

25  

MARKETED FOR WOMEN

Ironclad Evolution

23    

Tomboy Tools

13