August 2006
send to a friend printable version
How good is your state?
All but a handful of states have the authority to fine nursing homes that fail to provide proper care. But that doesn't mean they use it.

We asked all 50 states and the District of Columbia whether they had fined the nursing homes that we considered to be consistently poor performers. Those homes had appeared on our list of poor performers at least three out of four times.

The table below shows those results as well as how cooperative each state was in providing information.  If a state has not provided information to us or hasn't used its fining authority very much you should be very careful about monitoring the care a relative receives from the nursing homes in that state.


State

Number of nursing homes in state (as of September 2005)

Total number of nursing homes on the 2004 Watch List that had been on any Watch List at least 3 times

% of nursing homes in the sample of 3- or 4- time repeaters that were fined

Does state have the authority to fine nursing homes?

Did state provide data on fines levied and ownership?

Did state answer survey regarding regulatory performance?

AK 14 1 0% Yes Yes No
AL 229 10 * No Yes No
AR 236 8 unknown Yes No No
AZ 134 7 14% Yes Yes No
CA 1297 62 82% Yes Yes No
CO 214 10 0% Yes Yes Yes
CT 247 7 86% Yes Yes No
DC 20 1 100% Yes Yes No
DE 42 3 unknown Yes No No
FL 692 32 unknown Yes No Yes
GA 362 17 * No Yes No
HI 45 1 0% Yes Yes Yes
IA 455 17 94% Yes Yes Yes
ID 80 4 0% Yes Yes No
IL 810 36 50% Yes Yes No
IN 506 15 33% Yes Yes No
KS 366 13 38% Yes Yes No
KY 296 15 60% Yes Yes No
LA 305 8 unknown Yes No** No
MA 464 21 unknown Yes No No
MD 239 10 0% Yes Yes Yes
ME 116 4 75% Yes Yes No
MI 430 20 90% Yes Yes No
MN 409 22 32% Yes Yes Yes
MO 520 27 0% Yes Yes Yes
MS 204 10 * No Yes No
MT 100 2 * No Yes No
NC 420 23 * No Yes No
ND 83 4 0% Yes Yes Yes
NE 225 7 0% Yes, since 2002 Yes Yes
NH 82 1 0% Yes Yes No
NJ 361 14 21% Yes Yes Yes
NM 78 3 unknown Yes No Yes
NV 47 3 33% Yes Yes Yes
NY 659 34 74% Yes Yes Yes
OH 975 47 * No Yes Yes
OK 349 10 0% Yes Yes No
OR 138 7 86% Yes Yes No
PA 723 35 54% Yes Yes No
RI 92 4 0% Yes Yes No
SC 176 7 29% Yes Yes No
SD 111 5 0% Yes Yes No
TN 329 12 75% Yes Yes No
TX 1132 41 61% Yes Yes No
UT 92 3 33% Yes Yes No
VA 277 11 0% Yes Yes Yes
VT 41 1 0% Yes Yes No
WA 247 9 44% Yes Yes No
WI 399 19 100% Yes Yes Yes
WV 131 5 0% Yes Yes No
WY 39 3 * No Yes Yes
U.S. AVERAGE 314 14 36% Yes Yes No
* State does not have authority to levy fines.
** Note: Due to Hurricane Katrina, we did not make repeated requests for information to the state of Louisiana.