In this report
Overview
How to choose
Best blood-pressure monitors
Best blood-glucose meters
By the numbers
Blood-pressure monitors
CR Quick Recommendations
Ratings
Blood-glucose meters
CR Quick Recommendations
Ratings

TREATMENTS RATED
Find out which therapies work best for diabetes as well as for other conditions listed in this report.

COST-EFFECTIVE DRUGS
Learn more from our latest Best Buy Drugs report.

September 2008
send to a friend printable version
Self-test kits
Accuracy is important when choosing blood-glucose meters and blood-pressure monitors

VIDEO:
Blood-Pressure Monitors
All videos
Our tests of top-selling automatic blood-pressure monitors and blood-glucose meters found big differences in accuracy and consistency.

No one should settle for less than high-scoring models, since at-home monitoring can help people manage their blood pressure or diabetes and stave off such serious complications as heart disease, stroke, and kidney problems. Experts say relying on the readings of an inaccurate model could lead to inadequate care.

Regularly testing blood pressure at home provides vital data that people with hypertension and others at high risk for the disease can use and share with their doctors to determine whether the condition is under control. And blood-glucose monitoring at home can help many diabetics maintain optimal sugar levels by adjusting their insulin, medication levels, diet, and activity.

Our tests included laboratory measurements of the blood-pressure monitor and blood-glucose meter models’ accuracy and scores by panels of people who rated the devices’ ease of use and commented on various features. Here’s what we found:

Blood-glucose meter
Blood-glucose meters
HOMEWORK  Self-monitoring can help people with hypertension or diabetes manage their disease.
  • Automatic arm-type blood-pressure monitors were more accurate, overall, than wrist monitors. Four of the arm models tested were judged to be excellent, partly because of their accuracy: Omron Women’s Advanced Elite, CVS by Microlife Deluxe Advanced, Omron HEM-711AC, and ReliOn HEM-741CREL, a CR Best Buy at $40.

  • Only one blood-glucose meter, the OneTouch UltraMini, was rated excellent overall. It had top accuracy and consistency scores and was very easy to use. The Ascensia Contour blood-glucose meter was rated a very good choice because of its excellent accuracy and combination of features, and its very good consistency. The ReliOn Ultima, another very good choice, was also a CR Best Buy at just $9 (see blood-glucose meter Ratings, available to subscribers.) and its testing strips cost just 44 cents each.

The Duo-Care Combined Blood Glucose and Wrist Blood Pressure Monitor was judged poor in our blood-pressure tests. And though it was rated good in our blood-glucose tests, there’s cause for concern since it could accidentally be set to show sugar levels in foreign measurement units, rather than in U.S. units. That could lead to errors in medication dosages. There are better choices.