For complete access
Get full access to Ratings and recommendations on appliances, cars & trucks, electronic gear, and much more.  today to ConsumerReports.org.
June 2004
send to a friend printable version
We scour the claims for "miracle" cleaners 

Ads for do-it-all cleaners have been blasting TV viewers off the couch for years. These products purport to clean anything and everything from the laundry room to the living room. Operators are standing by.

So are our cleaning experts, who tested the new Mr. Clean Magic Eraser, the heavily hyped Didi Seven Ultra, and OxiClean. Each was good at something, but no single cleaner eliminated all our stains and grime. Here's what our tests found:


Mr. Clean Magic Eraser
$2.19 for two pads

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser
The claims:
Use it all over the house--on floors, walls, doors, appliances… even outside the house on patio furniture, car interiors, car wheels.

Best for: Grease, crayon, fingerprints, and marks on flat latex paint. Scuff marks on vinyl tile. Grease on stoves. Grime on appliance doors. Soap scum on tiles. Rubber trim on sneakers.

But: Left slight scrub marks or changed the surface luster on some painted surfaces. The spongelike Eraser disintegrates as you rub it. The label warns against use on finished wood, dark finishes, polished marble, granite, and glossy or satin finishes.
DiDi Seven Ultra
$8 for 2 ounces

DiDi Seven Ultra
The claims:
Removes hundreds of stains FAST…
including red wine, mayonnaise, ketchup, and salad dressing.

Best for: Laundry pretreatment on greasy stains and tannin/sugar stains such as red wine. Scuff marks on vinyl tile. Rubber trim on sneakers. Grease pencil on flat latex paint.

But: Failed to completely remove ink and lipstick from fabrics. Label warns against
use on leather, suede, and velvet. It worked fine on small scuffs on leather sneakers, but we would not use Didi Seven on a good pair of shoes.
OxiClean
$10 for a 6-pound tub

OxiClean
The claims:
Removes stains caused by blueberries, coffee, even red wine. Works on unfinished wood, lawn furniture, and linoleum.

Best for: Laundry
pretreatment on greasy stains and tannin/sugar stains such as red wine. Soap scum on ceramic tile. Rubber trim on sneakers. Scuff marks on vinyl tile.

But: Didn't fully remove ink and lipstick from fabrics and grease pencil on painted surfaces. Label warns against use on several materials, including leather, wool, silk, jewelry, latex-painted surfaces, wicker, and finished wood.