In this report
Overview
Siding options
Measuring up
January 2008
send to a friend printable version
Siding options

Weigh the look you like against price and upkeep.

The table below compares vinyl with four other common choices, based on the 3,200 square feet of siding needed to cover the average new 2,300-square-foot house. To choose the right siding for your needs, balance its appearance against its cost and maintenance requirements. Expect to add at least $3,000 for painting or staining. You’ll also pay extra for removing old siding and other related work.

  Vinyl.
Wood shingles/clapboard.
Fiber cement.
Masonry.
Simulated stucco.
 

VINYL

WOOD
SHINGLES/
CLAPBOARD

FIBER CEMENT

MASONRY

SIMULATED STUCCO

Siding cost (sq. ft.)

$0.45-$1.90

$0.67-$3.46

$0.84-$2.55

$2.46-$10-plus

$1.77-$2.39

Project cost

$7,575-$11,575

$9,975-$21,600

$7,125-$11,050

$12,285-$24,472

$22,425-$32,000

Pros

Mimics other siding. Low maintenance; requires no painting. Good airflow helps vent moisture. Won't warp, twist. Isn't damaged by water or insects.

Can be finished or left natural. Impact resistant, even in cold. Available primed and painted.

Looks like wood. Won't warp, twist, melt, or burn. Isn't damaged by insects. Impact resistant. Available primed and painted.

Includes brick, masonry, and stucco. Low maintenance. Isn't damaged by insects. Impact resistant. Won't melt or burn.

An alternative to cement-based stucco. Creates a waterproof barrier when properly applied. Impervious to insects.

Cons

Can chip or crack from cold-weather impacts. Can rattle, melt, or burn. Most expand and contract. Becomes brittle.

Higher-maintenance if painted or stained. Can be damaged by water and insects. Can warp, twist, or burn.

Requires periodic repainting, though less frequently than wood. May be damaged by water freezing and thawing.

Requires periodic refinishing if painted. May be damaged by water freezing and thawing. Brick veneers require some repointing; stucco requires some crack repair.

Can trap moisture--a problem that has resulted in litigation. May fade or require refinishing. Can be damaged by impacts. Can melt or burn.

Estimated life

25 to 50 years or more.

10 to 100 years.

50 years or more.

10 to 100 years or more.

20 to 30 years.

Cost-data research by RSMeans, a product line of Reed Construction Data, a leading provider of construction-information products. Data for house size and required materials provided by the National Association of Home Builders, an industry trade group.

Illustrations by Trevor Johnston