Generator Ratings

Last reviewed: June 2009

Ratings keySimilar models in small type,
comparable to tested model



Brand & Model Price Overall Score Test Results
Small portable units
(2,800 to 3,600 watts)
 
overall score
Emergency power
Power quality
Ease of use
Noise
Recommended Honda EU3000is $2,000
59
Good Excellent Good Excellent
Yamaha EF3000iSE EF3000iSEB 1,900
58
Fair Very good Very good Excellent
Recommended Craftsman 30250 590
46
Fair Excellent Excellent Good
Recommended Troy-Bilt 30248 500
45
Fair Good Good Good
Coleman PM0523202.17 550
39
Fair Fair Good Good
Midsized portable unit
(4,500 to 6,600 watts)
  overall score  
 
CR Best Buy Briggs & Stratton Elite Series 30242  CRBB 1,100
63
Very good Excellent Very good Excellent
Recommended Northstar 8000 TFG 2,000
62
Very good Good Very good Fair
Troy-Bilt 30245 700
50
Good Very good Good Good
Craftsman 30298 30521 880
49
Good Good Good Good
Recommended Coleman PM0545005 PM0435000, PM0525302.18, PM0545003, PM0545004, PM0545006 600
48
Good Fair Fair Good
Honda EG 5000 1,800
41
Very good Fair Good Fair
Stationary units
(6,000 to 12,000 watts)
  overall score  
 
CR Best Buy Kohler 12RESL 12RES  CRBB 3,700
95
Excellent Excellent Excellent Very good
Coleman PM400911 4,100
93
Excellent Very good Excellent Very good
Briggs & Stratton EmPower EM7 1,700
78
Very good Very good Very good Good
Guardian 04389 2,100
77
Very good Good Excellent Very good
 
 Includes a heavy-duty 25-foot adapter cord set with a generator-compatible plug at one end and four female outlets at the other.  Runs 4.4 hours when connected to a standard portable 20-pound liquid-propane tank.  Discontinued but might still be available.  Includes an automatic transfer switch.  When connected to a 250-gallon residential liquid propane tank; runtime essentially infinite with a natural-gas hookup.  Includes a manual transfer switch.

Guide to the Ratings

Overall score is based on emergency power, power quality, ease of use, run time, and noise. Emergency power is the capacity to deliver enough wattage to run essential devices such as a well pump, refrigerator, lights, and a heater or window a/c at once. Power quality is the ability to deliver consistent voltage. Ease of use includes starting, fuel shutoff, panel features, and (for portables) transport. Tested run time is how long the unit provided 80 percent capacity on a full tank of gasoline (portables) or a 250-gallon tank of liquid propane (stationary). Noise is at 50 feet with generator 3 feet from a building. Claimed output is the manufacturer’s rated maximum electrical output. Tested output is our measure of maximum sustained wattage. Price is approximate retail.