Scooters

Two models are great on gas, but these two-wheelers are not for everybody

Two scooters we just tested can get unbelievable fuel economy, and some buyers might view them as economical alternatives to a car. But be warned, scooters are not without some concerns about practicality and safety.

The Honda SH150i and the Aprilia Scarabeo 200 come with automatic transmissions, which are common on scooters these days. And both have the larger, motorcycle-like wheels and tires that we have found make for more secure handling and an improved ride. But those designs take away storage room for securing groceries, gear, or a helmet under the seat.

The Honda outscored the Aprilia in just about every one of our tests. Both of the scooters are made in Italy, and neither could be considered a low-priced model. Our Honda cost $4,499, and the Aprilia rang in at $3,499.

Gas prices have eased somewhat since 2008, when they peaked at more than $4 per gallon and prompted our first tests of scooters in 25 years. Still, scooters can be a second vehicle for some drivers.

A safety note: If you think a motor scooter might be for you, keep in mind that scooters are inherently more dangerous than cars. If you're new to riding scooters, sign up for professional instruction, and no matter how much experience you have, always wear protective gear that includes a full-face motorcycle helmet, gloves, boots, and thick clothing in highly visible colors. The Motorcycle Safety Foundation lists qualified instructional courses at www.msf-usa.org. Dealers can also guide you to proper instruction.