
Heavily advertised drugs usually aren’t the best first choice for health problems, according to the free Consumer Reports Best Buy Drugs program, which evaluates drug treatments for many common conditions based on effectiveness, safety, and cost.
Newer drugs are seldom more effective than older medications. Their shorter track record makes their safety less certain. And they almost always cost more, since they’re rarely available as generics. The table below shows how you could save up to $275 a month by using a comparable dose of a Best Buy Drug rather than a top brand-name drug. (People respond differently to drugs, so if you don’t get better with a recommended drug, talk with your doctor about switching.)
Ask your doctor if you might benefit from any of these treatments:
Once a commonly used prescription pain reliever, this chemical cousin of aspirin was eclipsed in the 1990s by the huge marketing push for other nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). But it’s still an effective and inexpensive choice for pain relief, which is why it qualifies as a Consumer Reports Best Buy Drug.
Although widely used in other countries, medicated creams and patches aren’t as popular in the U.S. That’s a shame because experts at the federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality recently concluded that topical NSAIDs were just as effective as pills at relieving the pain of osteoarthritis. Topical treatments can cause skin reactions, but pills affect the stomach and blood more. Over-the-counter creams include Aspercreme and Myoflex.
An extensive body of research shows that diuretics such as hydrochlorothiazide (HydroDiuril and generic) or chlorothiazide (Diuril and generic) lower blood pressure just as well as newer and more expensive alternatives—including ACE inhibitors, beta-blockers, and calcium-channel blockers. And they are more likely to prevent heart failure and stroke. Yet many physicians still regularly prescribe those other drugs, especially for people with other cardiovascular risk factors, such as high blood sugar or cholesterol levels. A major study has confirmed that diuretics are superior, even for people in those groups.
Besides getting treatment, people with asthma should rid their environment of allergens. You can also ease symptoms by shedding excess pounds and treating sleep apnea.
| Condition | Brand-name or top-selling drug | CR Best Buy Drug | Monthly savings | Comments | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Attention deficit/ hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) | Strattera One 18-mg pill per day $217 |
VS. | Methylphenidate Two 20-mg pills per day $40 |
$177 |
Make sure you or your child has an accurate diagnosis; ADHD drugs might be overused. |
| Constipation | Amitiza Two 8-mcg pills per day $220-294 |
VS. | Polyethylene glycol powder 17 g per day $23 |
$197—271 |
Polyethylene glycol is available over the counter. Try a high-fiber diet, combined with a fiber supplement if necessary, before drugs. |
| Diabetes (type 2) |
Actos One 30-mg pill per day $241 |
VS. | Metformin Two 1,000-mg pills per day $18 |
$223 |
Many people with diabetes need to take two drugs, and often metformin is a good first step. |
| Enlarged prostate | Flomax One 0.4-mg capsule per day $123 |
VS. | Doxazosin One 2-mg tablet per day $9 |
$114 |
To minimize side effects, start with a low dose. If that doesn’t help, consider another low-cost alpha-blocker. |
| Heartburn | Nexium One 20-mg pill per day $215 |
VS. | Omeprazole One 20-mg pill per day $15 |
$200 |
Omeprazole is available over the counter. See a doctor if you have heartburn two or more times per week for several weeks. |
| High LDL (bad) cholesterol | Lipitor One 10-mg pill per day $101 |
VS. | Lovastatin One 20-mg pill per day $18 |
$83 |
If you need to lower LDL by more than 30 percent, simvastatin can be a good option. If you have had a heart attack, have heart disease, or are at high risk, talk with your doctor about your drug options. |
| Insomnia | Lunesta One 2-mg pill at bedtime $93 for 15 pills |
VS. | Zolpidem One 10-mg pill at bedtime $35 for 15 pills |
$58 |
Don’t take sleeping pills every night for more than 10 days. Zolpidem varies in price for 15 pills. Shop around. |
| Osteoarthritis, joint pain | Celebrex Two 200-mg pills per day $296 |
VS. | Ibuprofen Three 400-mg pills per day $21 |
$275 |
Celebrex may be a good choice for people with a history of stomach problems if they are at low risk for heart disease or stroke. |