Donate |
Preview: To see full article and/or Ratings, Subscribe Now!

Cadillac XTS and Lincoln MKS reviews

Two big, opulent American sedans fall short of expectations

Consumer Reports magazine: January 2013

A face-off between the flagship luxury sedans from Cadillac and Lincoln used to be a center-ring event. Not anymore. With German and Asian automakers continually raising the bar in this category, the new Cadillac XTS and the updated Lincoln MKS are now little more than a sideshow among more inviting and higher-rated models.

Of the two, the XTS is a considerably better car. But its overall road-test score still places it near the bottom of this competitive class and well short of a top-rated Audi and Infiniti. The MKS scores too low for us to recommend and sits in the cellar of our luxury-sedan ratings.

The $57,200 XTS replaces the plush DTS and sporty STS sedans at the top of Cadillac’s lineup. It is wonderfully luxurious, with a very spacious and well-appointed cabin and a roomy trunk. But the car lacks the silky ride you’d expect from a big Caddy, and although it handles well for its size, it doesn’t have the finesse or brawn of the better German and Asian competitors.

The XTS is also hampered by a new high-tech infotainment system called CUE (for Cadillac User Experience). The system is so convoluted and frustrating that it detracts from the XTS’s pampering environment.

At $50,070 for our loaded test car, the MKS costs much less than the XTS and offers plenty of features. But they don’t make up for the car’s basic flaws, including a cramped driving position and limited visibility. Moreover, handling is ungainly, the ride is neither isolating nor adequately composed, and the 3.7-liter  V6 engine is coarse. A recent update added the MyLincoln Touch infotainment system, making the controls confusing, distracting, and frustrating. Buyers would do much better with the roomy, well-appointed, and less expensive Chrysler 300 or Hyundai’s Genesis or Equus.

Sign In or Subscribe to see full article and/or Ratings.

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters!
Choose from safety, health, cars, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Latest From Consumer Reports

PREPAID PLAN COMPARISON
How to choose the right prepaid phone plan See which of four common phone-usage scenarios fits your needs.
LEAF BLOWER REVIEWS
Leaf blowers that don't raise a ruckusVideo Gas models are less noisy than they used to be, but electrics are quietest.
SUV REVIEWS
On the road: 10 best vehicles for family vacations When you're traveling with a crowd, comfort is key for an enjoyable trip.
VACUUM REVIEWS
5 ways to unclutter and clean up your home If you've procrastinated this spring, try these organizing and cleaning tips.
SMART PHONE REVIEWS
Get the best deal on the new Samsung Galaxy S 5 The lowest up-front price could cost you more in the long run.
WASHING MACHINE REVIEWS
Best appliances: Top-rated washer-and-dryer pairs These laundry duos cleaned up in our latest lab tests.

Connect

and safety with
subscribers and fans

Follow us on:

Cars

Cars New Car Price Report
Find out what the dealers don't want you to know! Get dealer pricing information on a new car with the New Car Price Report.

Order Your Report

Mobile

Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more