October 2003
send to a friend printable version
Shredders can foil ID thieves

Fellowes P400C-2 shredder.
Fellowes P400C-2
A shredder can be a valuable tool for getting rid of old documents that contain credit-card account numbers, your birthdate, and your Social Security number--pay dirt for identity thieves.

Our tests of shredders priced from $15 to $130, the types sold in office-supply stores, yielded two main findings:
• Cross-cut shredders worked the best. The other kind, strip shredders, were fast but they left long paper bands that could be reassembled relatively easily.
• Expect to pay at least $40. Less-expensive shredders are typically the strip-shredder variety. At $130, the top-performing shredder in our tests was the priciest. But it could shred the most per session, 920 pages. The next best shredded less than one-third as much per session, or 270 pages. It is just $50, however, and you may find that it meets your needs.


Quick Ratings Shredders
 
Within types, in order of productivity.  
Brand & model Price paid

Max. sheets/
session

Max. sheets/
pass
Max. run
time/cool
down (min.)
Cross-cut style Recommended for maximum security

Fellowes Powershred PS60C-2

$130 920 8 10-12 on / 20 off

Fellowes Paper Shredder P400C-2

50 270 5 5-7 on / 15 off

Fellowes Paper Shredder P50CM

40 87 5 2 on / 15 off

Aurora Metallic Color Series 5 Sheet Shredder with
Wastebasket AS501X-MS

40 74 5 2 on / 4 off
Strip-cut style Not recommended for maximum security

GBC Shredmaster Shredmaster 70S

70 463 8 3 on / 30 off

Tech Solutions 9 Sheet Strip Cut Paper Shredder with Wastebasket TS-2550

15 281 9 2 on / 4 off