
We compared the agencies' scoring rigor by aligning "good" grades on the save tier and calculating the percentage of insurers that scored higher.
| Rating agency | Number of life insurers rated | Percent rated "Excellent" |
|---|---|---|
| Standard & Poor's | 282 | 81% |
| A.M. Best | 598 | 66 |
| Moody's | 140 | 55 |
| Fitch | 452 | 47 |
| TheStreet.com | 625 | 11 |
This article appeared in the May 2009 issue of Consumer Reports Money Adviser.