Consumer Reports Money Adviser
Subscribe now to get more expert financial advice you can trust.
February 2006
send to a friend printable version
All that #%*#@!* paperwork: What to keep and what to toss
Chances are you're storing a ton more than you really need to


Are you a "Shoebox Sally"? You are if you stockpile more than a year's worth of annual reports, monthly credit-card statements, and weekly pay stubs, says Dee Lee, a financial planner in Harvard, Mass. The same goes for most insurance policies, bank statements, and canceled checks.

If that's not enough to get you to fire up the paper shredder, keep reading.

Hanging on to every scrap of paper is not just a fire hazard; it can also be an impediment to heirs or caretakers sorting through your belongings down the road. That said, what you keep and how long you keep it can be just as important as where you keep it.


HIDE AND SEEK

Lee tells of one elderly woman who had sewn about $500,000 worth of stock certificates into her curtain hems, where they could have been destroyed, lost, or stolen. If you're holding certificates, have them transferred to a brokerage account. U.S. savings bonds should be converted to electronic form. If you must keep paper copies, stash a list of the serial numbers and issue dates in a separate location.

Misplaced paperwork isn't the only problem you'll encounter when sorting out another person's assets. After her mother's death in September 2005, Andrea Spatz, a financial planner in Los Angeles, had to wade through reams of canceled checks, annual reports, and other paperwork that had been squirreled away over the decades. Also, she realized that her mother's safe-deposit-box key was missing. Eventually, Spatz found it hidden in a drawer with her mother's underthings, but she had to make repeated trips to her mother's home to find it. The location of her mother's car title remains a mystery. "She had a list showing where everything was, but it hadn't been updated," Spatz laments. "Every one of her friends said, 'I don't envy you.' "


URGED TO PURGE

Spatz and other financial experts say people typically save far too much stuff or in some cases far too little. And the important items usually aren't well organized or easy to grab, as victims of Hurricane Katrina discovered after fleeing their homes without bank-account numbers and other important documents.

The chart below tells you how long to save important papers, including wills and insurance policies, and where to keep them. But before you start tossing, make sure you have a working shredder, or be prepared to start ripping. Identity thieves thrive on account numbers and other personal information on tossed paperwork. Also, organize the documents you keep in loose-leaf binders or in file folders where they'll be easy to find. You might also want to use a scanner to preserve some items, such as tax returns, on CDs, says Evelyn Zohlen, a financial planner with Inspired Financial in Garden Grove, Calif.

Finally, make a list of your important papers and their locations that you or the person you've designated to carry on your affairs can consult for quick access. Include details about how to find your safe-deposit-box key, the combination to your home safe, and your computer log-ons and passwords. Give the list to loved ones and be vigilant about updating it.

It's also a good idea to keep copies of your most important documents in a single location so they'll be easy to grab in case you need to evacuate your home. Some items to include in that pile: passports; account numbers for your bank, broker, and utilities and other bills; family immunization records; Social Security numbers; computer PIN numbers; and photos of your family and pets for identification. "You should be able to grab that stuff, put it in a suitcase, and be out of your house in a half-hour," Lee says.



Document When to toss Where to keep originals/copies
BANKING
Bank-deposit slips After you reconcile your statements Home
Canceled checks Generally after one year; 7 years for checks that support tax filings Home
Certificates of deposit After matures Home
Check registers After one year Home
Check statements After one year Home
Credit-card statements After one year; 7 years if needed to support tax filings Home
Loan documents When repay loan Home
Loan-discharge notices Never Safe-deposit box
Pay stubs When you get a new one Home
ESTATE
Health-care proxy When updated Safe-deposit box/primary-care physician, attorney, anyone named to make decisions on your behalf
Living trust When updated Safe-deposit box/successor trustee, attorney
Living will When updated Safe-deposit box/attorney, executor
Power of attorney When updated Safe-deposit box/designee, attorney
Will When updated Safe-deposit box/attorney, executor
INSURANCE
Annually renewed insurance policies After renewal Home
Insurance inventory When updated Safe-deposit box
Permanent life
(whole life, etc.)
Never Safe-deposit box
Term life After the term expires Safe-deposit box
INVESTMENTS
Brokerage statements Hold until you sell the securities, then hold with your tax return for 7 years. Home
Purchase confirmations and 1099s Hold until securities are sold, then put with your tax returns. Home
Savings bonds When matures Best to convert to electronic bonds at the U.S. Treasury. Otherwise, place in safe-deposit box, keeping a list of serial numbers at home.
Stock certificates Should not be held Transfer paper certificates to a brokerage account; consult your financial adviser.
PERSONAL
Birth certificate Never Safe-deposit box
Death certificates Never Safe-deposit box
Marriage license Never Safe-deposit box
Military-discharge papers Never Safe-deposit box
Social Security card Never Safe-deposit box
PRODUCT PURCHASES
Car title When you sell your vehicle Safe-deposit box
Receipts When warranty expires; after 7 years if needed to support tax returns Home
Warranties When expires Home
RETIREMENT
Employer defined-benefit plan communications Never Home
401(k) statements When you get a new one Home
Social Security statements When you get a new one Home
TAX
Personal state and federal tax returns and supporting documents After 7 years Home
    Note: For documents in a safe-deposit box, it's a good idea to keep copies
    at home as well.