July 2008
Geography and health care
The amount of medical care that people get for serious illnesses varies enormously from place to place. In the last two years
of life, the average patient spent 11 days in the hospital in Bend, Ore., and 35 days in Manhattan. In those same two years,
patients visited the doctor an average of 34 times in Ogden, Utah, and 109 times in Los Angeles.
The Dartmouth Atlas based those findings on the Medicare claims records of millions of patients who died from (in order of prevalence) congestive heart failure, chronic pulmonary (lung) disease, cancer, dementia, coronary artery disease, chronic kidney failure, peripheral vascular (circulatory) disease, diabetes with organ damage, and severe chronic liver disease. Together those ailments account for about 90 percent of deaths of people older than 65.
Over the years, Dartmouth research has yielded some startling insights:
The Dartmouth Atlas based those findings on the Medicare claims records of millions of patients who died from (in order of prevalence) congestive heart failure, chronic pulmonary (lung) disease, cancer, dementia, coronary artery disease, chronic kidney failure, peripheral vascular (circulatory) disease, diabetes with organ damage, and severe chronic liver disease. Together those ailments account for about 90 percent of deaths of people older than 65.
Over the years, Dartmouth research has yielded some startling insights:
- The local supply of doctors and hospitals has more influence on the amount and type of care that patients receive than their
actual medical conditions have. The more medical resources a region has, the more aggressive the treatments are.
- In the regions that deliver the most care, patients have a slightly higher death rate than patients with the same conditions
treated in areas that treat less aggressively.
- Patients treated most aggressively are no more satisfied with their care.
- The cost differences are vast. Average Medicare spending over the last two years of life for all hospitals ranged from a high of $81,143 in Manhattan to a low of $29,116 in Dubuque, Iowa.
