Back to previous page
date: 2/22/2006
Best Buy Drugs to treat migraines
If you are taking a drug called a triptan to treat your migraines, there are safe, effective drug choices that could save you money. In this report we identify some Best Buy Drug options that you can discuss with your doctor and that explain the difference between different types of headache.
Subscribe to ConsumerReportsHealth.org for more information about migraines and more than 100 difficult-to-manage medical conditions and to compare your options with our exclusive Treatment Ratings.
OUR RECOMMENDATIONS—A SUMMARY

Know your options

CRBestBuyDrugs.org is a free public-education service presented here by ConsumerReportsHealth.org

Download our free PDF report to learn more about choosing the right triptan drug
Triptans are effective medicines used to treat migraine headaches. For about 60 percent of people who take one, a triptan reduces pain within two hours. While complete pain relief is not common, it can be enhanced if you take a triptan early in a migraine attack. The triptans also help relieve other migraine symptoms, such as nausea, vomiting, and sensitivity to light, noise, and motion.

If you have mild and less frequent migraine attacks, try other pain relievers first, including aspirin, an NSAID (such as ibuprofen), Excedrin Migraine or Excedrin Extra Strength. If your migraines are moderate to severe, frequent, and/or disrupt your life, you are likely to need a triptan.

However, the triptans should not be taken by people with certain conditions because of risks they pose to the heart. This includes people with coronary artery disease or angina (chest pain), those who have had a heart attack or stroke, and people who have peripheral vascular disease, uncontrolled high blood pressure, diabetes, or who smoke.

For Subscribers
In addition, the triptans should be prescribed with caution for men over 40, women over 50, people who have high cholesterol, diabetes, or who are significantly overweight and those with a family history of early heart disease or stroke.

There are seven triptans and they differ in their effectiveness and the side effects they cause. They are expensive drugs (with none yet available as a generic) and tend to be priced about the same on a per pill basis ($21 to $26). The nasal spray and injectable forms cost more. We have chosen three triptans as Consumer Reports Best Buy Drugs:
  • Naratriptan (Amerge) - for people with milder migraines who are sensitive to triptan side effects and/or have longer-duration migraines
  • Rizatriptan (Maxalt) - for people with moderate to severe headache pain and symptoms
  • Sumatriptan (Imitrex) - for people with moderate to severe headache pain and symptoms
Each of these three drugs has unique strengths, which are discussed in detail in our full report. They are chosen as Best Buys largely on their clinical merits and not their cost. The cost for triptan treatment depends entirely on how often you have to use one, since triptans are only taken when a migraine occurs. Frequent use can be expensive.

Warning: Certain antidepressants interact dangerously with migraine drugs

In July 2006 the Food and Drug Administration issued a warning that a potentially life-threatening condition known as serotonin syndrome can result from taking both an antimigraine triptan, such as sumatriptan (Imitrex), and a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI), such as sertraline (Zoloft), or a serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (SNRI), such as duloxetine (Cymbalta). All three types of drugs boost the amount of serotonin in the brain, which can be good up to a point. But when the migraine medication is used in conjunction with a serotonin-raising antidepressant, the body may accumulate too much serotonin, causing side effects such as nausea, diarrhea, and rapid changes in blood pressure and pulse rate.

What you can do: Inform your doctor right away if you take both a triptan and an SSRI or SNRI. Seek medical attention if you experience the symptoms above or loss of coordination, fever, tremor, hallucinations or vomiting. If you have not had problems, don't stop taking the medications on your own until you talk to a doctor. You may not need to stop using the drugs, says Fred Sheftell, M.D., president-elect of the American Headache Society. Since the incidence of full-blown serotonin syndrome is rare, the benefits of taking the medicines outweigh the risks in some cases. See Consumer Reports Best Buy Drugs for more information on triptans and antidepressants.

What kind of headache do you have?

Ordinary periodic 'tension- type' Chronic daily1 Cluster Migraine
  • Generally mild in intensity
  • Does not occur regularly, just every once in a while
  • Usually lasts ½ to 3 hours
  • Dull ache
  • Pain on both sides of head
  • Not throbbing
  • No nausea or vomiting
  • No visual disturbance or auras2
  • Mild sensitivity to light or noise, but only one and never both
  • Can be mild or severe in intensity
  • Occurs at least 15 days per month for 3 months
  • Pain can be dull or stabbing and jolting (often described as ice-pick-like)
  • Lasts at least 4 hours if untreated
  • No nausea or vomiting
  • No visual disturbance or auras
  • Mild sensitivity to light and noise, if any
  • May result from overuse of pain relievers
  • Pain is usually severe and centered on one side, behind the eye or temple
  • Pain is sharp, stabbing
  • Short attacks usually last 30 minutes to 1 hour but can be up to 3 hours if untreated
  • Can be more than one attack a day and usually up to three
  • Comes in waves, with attacks daily or near-daily for 2 weeks to 3 months and then disappears for months or even years
  • Pain is moderate to severe and often located on one side
  • Often pulsating or throbbing
  • Periodic attacks (several a year to one or two a month) that last from 4 to 72 hours if untreated3
  • Nausea with or without vomiting is quite common
  • Sensitivity to movement, light and/or noise common
  • May have auras or visual disturbances4
1. There are several types of chronic daily headache. Some may be the tension-type headaches that occur 15 or more days a month. Others present with different symptoms, such as stabbing head pains that may come and go throughout the day. In the latter case, doctors will first try to rule out whether some other condition or disease is causing the headaches.
2. Auras are often visual disturbances but can also feel like numbness or weakness on one side of the body. For example, you may see dots or shapes or flickering lights. They can obscure your vision. Auras are associated with migraine and usually precede a migraine attack. See the migraine column.
3. Experience of at least five attacks that fit the criteria in this column leads to a diagnosis of migraine. Untreated, some attacks can last up to 72 hours. Migraine sufferers average about one attack a month but 10 percent of them will get an attack every week. And 20 percent have attacks that sometimes last two to three days.
4. About one in six migraine sufferers have auras. See note 2. Some migraine sufferers also have a sensation of numbness or a "pins and needles" feeling at various points on their body.


This site is for your information only. For medical advice, consult a health professional.