TV Antenna Review: Top Picks From Consumer Reports' Testing

The right model will get you free over-the-air TV and make it easier to cut the cord with cable

TV antenna Illustration: Consumer Reports, iStock

TV antennas might seem like a relic of a bygone era, when the number of channels you received could be counted on one hand. But as consumers try to trim their ever-escalating cable and satellite TV bills, antennas are making a comeback. In fact, about one-quarter of all broadband households now use an antenna, according to research firm Parks Associates.

Consumer Reports’ latest tests of indoor TV antennas of all shapes and sizes in urban and suburban homes found that most locations were able to receive dozens of free over-the-air channels. (Outdoor antennas tend to perform even better, but they’re not practical for everyone.)

That’s good news for the growing number of people who are dumping traditional cable packages but keeping streaming services such as Netflix and Amazon Prime. An antenna can supply their live TV, including local news and other broadcasts.

Become a member of Consumer Reports to get access to our TV Screen Optimizer, which will help you get the perfect picture on your TV in just minutes. Join today to get started.

More on Antennas and TVs

Even if you subscribe to a cable-replacement service that brings you channels such as AMC and HGTV, you might still want an antenna. These services—which include DirecTV Stream, FuboTV, Hulu + Live TV, Sling TV, and YouTube TV—don’t always provide local programming in all markets. An indoor TV antenna can help fill that gap.

If you live near a major TV market, you’ll probably get many local stations—ABC, CBS, Fox, and NBC, plus PBS and Telemundo—using a TV antenna. But there are also now dozens of digital "subchannels" under the primary channels. These offer additional programming, such as old TV shows, B movies, and niche content. Websites such as AntennaWeb and the FCC’s DTV Reception Maps page can give you an idea of which stations you might expect to receive.

As a bonus, the picture quality you get from your indoor TV antenna might be better than what you get from cable. “The signals may be less compressed,” says Claudio Ciacci, lead television tester for Consumer Reports.

In addition to a TV antenna, all you need to watch your local stations is a TV equipped with a digital TV tuner, something included in almost all TVs since 2007.

Tips for Antenna Shoppers

The antennas we tested ranged in price from $10 to more than $100—and we found little correlation between price and performance. The antenna that pulled in the most stations for most of our testers cost just $35, and several pricier models were in the lower half of our rankings.

We included some amplified TV antennas in our review. These models can boost signal strength to help pull in stations that might otherwise be on the fringe. But our tests showed that amplified antennas weren’t always more effective than nonamplified models—they can also amplify noise and distortion, and overload reception from closer stations.

The number of channels you receive will depend on your location and environment, as well as the placement of the antenna in your home. You may need to try several models before finding the best antenna for your needs. That’s why we strongly recommend purchasing from a retailer with a no-hassle return policy. Also, it’s a good idea to regularly rescan for channels, because you might have missed some the last time you scanned. And use our tips on where to place your antenna to get the best reception.

Before you buy a new TV, check our buying guide and ratings of models from all the major brands. You’ll also find our exclusive brand reliability information based on feedback from more than 118,000 readers. Every set we evaluate goes through a battery of tests, backed by expert viewing panels, to determine high-definition picture quality and UHD performance with 4K content.

What We Found

We had 10 testers evaluate each of the indoor TV antennas at their homes, which were scattered around the New York tristate area. Most locations were within a 40-mile radius of the Empire State Building in Manhattan but one was 64 miles away. Our test results should be useful for pointing you in the right direction to models you might consider, but there are a number of variables that can affect antenna performance in your home.

We tested antennas near a window and away from a window, near the TV. In the tests near a window, the three indoor TV antennas that stood out for performance were the Winegard FlatWave FL5500A, the Winegard FlatWave Amped Pro TH-3000, and the ClearStream Eclipse Amplified TV Antenna.

But there were a number of other models that also did well. And a few were significantly cheaper, at $20 or less, including the 1byone (Updated 2020) Ultra-Thin Amplified HD Digital TV Antenna, the Naxa NAA-308, and the Mohu Leaf Metro.

In the rankings below, you’ll see two figures.

The "percentage of stations received" is a weighted average of the total number of stations that a particular antenna received at each location, divided by the number of stations we found to be available at that location through all our testing.

The "percentage of UHF/VHF stations received" breaks out the two broad categories of signals that were found at each location by any given tester, across all antennas. Any time a new UHF or VHF channel was found during a given scan, it was added to the total number available for that tester.

(Back in the early analog TV signal days, most major broadcast channels—say, 2 through 13—were in the lower-frequency VHF band. Now they’re scattered across both bands, so it’s important to buy an antenna that does well across the board.)

You can see more details on how we tested antennas below. Note that the prices listed may be different from the prices you see at retailers right now. We suggest you click the buying links to get the most up-to-date pricing.

Become a member to read the full article and get access to digital ratings.

We investigate, research, and test so you can choose with confidence.