Home >  Cars  >  Suzuki and Consumers Union agree on dismissal of lawsuit

Suzuki and Consumers Union agree on dismissal of lawsuit

Last updated: April 2010

Consumers Union of the U.S., Inc., ("CU") and the Suzuki Motor Corporation are pleased to announce that the product disparagement lawsuit regarding the Suzuki Samurai sport-utility vehicle, filed by Suzuki against CU in 1996 in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, has been settled and will be dismissed.

In the process of settlement discussions between the parties, the parties have acknowledged their mutual respect for each other in that Suzuki recognizes CU's stated commitment for objective and unbiased testing and reporting, and CU recognizes Suzuki's stated commitment for designing, manufacturing, and marketing safe vehicles.

CU and Suzuki disagree with respect to the validity of CU's short course avoidance maneuver tests of the Samurai in 1988. Suzuki disputes the validity of the protocol and findings of these tests, and CU stands by its test protocol and findings. However, CU and Suzuki agree on the following:

Mutual Respect Acknowledged

  • CU recognizes Suzuki's stated commitment for designing, manufacturing and marketing safe vehicles.
  • Suzuki recognizes CU's stated commitment for objective and unbiased testing and reporting.

Background

In 1988, when CU tested the Samurai, small SUVs as a category were new to the market. The Samurai was among the earliest entrants to this category. The Samurai has not been sold by Suzuki in the United States since 1995. Studies performed by the U.S. government have shown that the Samurai's real world rollover accident performance was within a range with other utility vehicles.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others have criticized the CU tests because of driver variation. CU disagrees with NHTSA's position. NHTSA uses robotic controllers in its rollover testing of SUVs to minimize driver variation.

CU has never questioned the safety of any other Suzuki model it has tested. It has praised the Suzuki Sidekick and recommended the Suzuki Vitara/XL7.

Clarification

CU's 1996 statement that the 1988 Samurai "easily rolls over in turns" was limited to the severe turns in CU's short course avoidance maneuver. CU's use of the adverb "easily" may have been misconstrued and misunderstood. CU never intended to state or imply that the Samurai easily rolls over in routine driving conditions. Subsequent to 1988, several other SUVs have tipped up either in CU's tests or in U.S. government tests.

CU and Suzuki agree not to refer to the Samurai testing or rating or their litigation in any advertising, promotional or fundraising materials. CU agrees to remove from CU's website entitled consumersrighttoknow.org those portions that refer to their litigation and Suzuki. Suzuki agrees to remove its website entitled suzukivcu.com.

CU and Suzuki may refer to its prior publications concerning the Samurai rating or testing provided they also furnish the recipient with a copy of the Joint Public Statement or a reference to a webpage containing the Joint Public Statement.

No Demand For Monetary Compensation

The subject lawsuit has been dismissed, and Suzuki has not demanded or received monetary compensation.

   

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters!
Choose from safety, health, cars, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Cars News

Where to chow down on your road trips

If you're a foodie, you might envision experiencing your very own version of "Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives" during a Memorial Day or summer road trip. But unlike Guy Fieri and his apparently endle...

Teaching teen drivers at Street Survival school

On a recent Saturday, over 30 teenage drivers (most accompanied by their parents) made their way to Consumer Reports Auto Test Center in rural Connecticut for an experience that could one day sav...

Magellan SmartGPS navigator may be too smart for its own good

Magellan has just introduced its latest connected device to the world of portable navigation with their new SmartGPS, and we're already well into testing this creative new device in our lab and o...

Just in: Our new Ram 1500 pickup is tons of truck

Memorial Day weekend is an American invention. Just like corndogs. And what is more patriotic than a full-sized pickup? New at our track is one of the top contenders--a four-wheel-drive Ram 1500 ...

Should I call 911 to report a dangerous driver?

We see it all the time. A car swerving on the road, cutting people off, the driver oblivious to the danger they are causing. Is there something you can do? Yes, drivers should speak up to ensure ...
More news

Connect

Discuss products
and safety with
subscribers and fans

Follow us on:

Cars

Cars New Car Price Report
Find out what the dealers don't want you to know! Get a great price on a new car with the Consumer Reports New Car Price Report.

Order Your Report

Mobile

Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more