June 2001
send to a friend printable version
from our president
This monthly letter to subscribers from Consumers Union President Jim Guest highlights the critical consumer issues behind our current reports. See archived letters.

 

Food-safety roulette

Jim Guest
For years, like many consumers, I didn't think twice about the safety of the food at the supermarket, assuming it was effectively protected by government standards and careful oversight. Much of the time our trust in the food supply is justified. But we've learned that some staples, such as hot dogs, lettuce, and ground beef, can and have caused outbreaks of food poisoning. Recent reports and statistics--and Consumers Union's own work--emphasize that our food-safety system could be better.

The national Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that each year, food-borne pathogens cause 325,000 hospitalizations and 76 million illnesses, resulting in 5,000 deaths. Though technological advances, such as pasteurization, have nearly eradicated some forms of disease, other hazards have cropped up.

Changes over the past century in how food is produced, processed, and transported have created new risks for contamination. For example, with mass production, a single batch of hamburger could contain meat from more than 100 cows. If just one of those cows were contaminated with enough E. coli 0157:H7, hundreds of people could get sick from burgers made with the contaminated meat, if it were not properly handled and cooked. Environmental hazards can also endanger the food supply, as we found when we tested canned tuna for mercury.

Changes in our lifestyles and eating habits can create some unexpected risks. If food from a salad bar or open buffet is not held at the proper temperature--or, again, is not properly handled--it could make you ill.

Our present food-safety system is simply not designed to meet today's needs or tomorrow's threats. With responsibility spread among a dozen agencies interpreting some 35 different laws--some of them almost 100 years old--there's no clear authority or coordination of food-safety oversight. Cheese pizza, for example, is regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), while pizza with pepperoni is regulated by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). Shell eggs are regulated by the FDA; most processed egg products by the USDA. Meat slaughtering and packing plants, which fall under USDA jurisdiction, undergo daily inspections, while years can pass between inspections at facilities under FDA jurisdiction.

Imports from all over the world line the shelves of our supermarkets, some from countries where food-safety standards and practices are not as stringent as ours. Yet, on average, only 1 percent of shipments of imported food under the FDA's jurisdiction is inspected.

The patchwork of regulations and agencies--and the inconsistent enforcement of standards--leaves American consumers playing a kind of food-safety roulette. Our current food-safety system is ill-equipped to stem the tide of food-borne illnesses caused by the organisms we know to be dangerous or to deal effectively with new, unfamiliar threats, such as mad-cow disease.

The General Accounting Office (GAO) has concluded that "it is unlikely that fundamental, lasting improvements in food safety will occur until systematic legislative and structural changes are made to the entire food safety system."

CU, along with other consumer groups and the GAO, recommends establishing a single federal agency to set up-to-date food-safety standards, enforce them, and carry out safety research. This new food-safety agency would be more focused and accountable, and better able to direct resources to areas of greatest need, than the present piecemeal system.

To further this mission, many of our laws on food safety should be amended and updated, incorporating the latest scientific methods, to protect public health. One example: the Federal Meat Inspection Act, which was last rewritten in 1967 and lacks appropriate enforcement powers.

In 21st-century America, we should no longer have to worry about getting sick--much less, dying--from unsafe, contaminated food.

Jim Guest's signature.

Jim Guest
President