Would you buy that mattress again?

17,000 subscribers rate their beds and where they bought them

Last reviewed: October 2009
October 2009 issue cover This article appeared in
October 2009 Consumer Reports Magazine.
Latest on Mattresses
Illustration of what people are dreaming about while sleeping on their mattress
Illustration by Jing and Mike

Buying a bed is no picnic. Comparison shopping is almost impossible because different retailers rarely call a model by the same name. And you're apt to make that expensive decision after trying out a bed for just a few minutes in the store.

But our new survey might help. We found real differences when we asked 17,444 online subscribers who bought a bed in the past few years about their satisfaction with the brand and the store.

Forty-one percent said they'd definitely buy the mattress brand they currently own if they had to do it over. Forty-three percent said they'd probably buy it again. An unhappy 16 percent said they'd probably or definitely pick something else. Here are the details:

Some brands were better

Respondents who bought Tempur-Pedic, Original Mattress Factory brand, and Select Comfort mattresses were much more satisfied than those who bought Spring Air and Stearns & Foster models. They were significantly more likely to say they would definitely buy those brands again.

Any new mattress beats an old one

Seventy-two percent of readers said their new bed improved their sleep. If yours is uncomfortable, consider replacing it even if it's only five or so years old.

Satisfaction at what price?

Seventy-eight percent of those who spent more than $4,000 said they were highly satisfied with their purchase. But 66 percent of those who spent less than $1,000 were also highly satisfied.

Problem sleepers had a preference

Among those who said they had problems sleeping, 78 percent said that a new bed, any new bed, improved their ability to get a good night's rest; 42 percent said the new mattress greatly improved their sleep.

Problem sleepers said Tempur-Pedic (made of memory foam) and Select Comfort (a line of adjustable air mattresses) provided the most relief. More than 60 percent of long-suffering sleepers who bought either of the two brands said their sleep was very much improved. Conversely, Stearns & Foster and Spring Air disproportionately aggravated the difficulties of problem sleepers, worsening the condition of about 10 percent of those who bought them.

An in-store tryout is a good idea

Seventy-two percent of those who invested at least 10 minutes (for instance, lying down on each side, back, and stomach) were highly satisfied with their mattress purchase compared with 62 percent who didn't. A rest test isn't foolproof—12 percent of those surveyed were at least somewhat dissatisfied with their new mattress even if they tried it first—but at least it gives you a fighting chance.

Don't pay full price

The suggested retail price of a mattress is pure fiction. Discounts of 50 percent or more are common. In our survey, only 36 percent of respondents tried haggling. Among those who tried, 72 percent got a lower price.

Rating the retailers

Most respondents were pleased with their purchase experience. Seventy-one percent were very satisfied; 32 percent said they were completely satisfied.

The top-ranked seller, The Original Mattress Factory, was a standout for both service and selection. Costco was also highly rated, even though it (and Sam's Club) earned the lowest scores for service and selection. Across the board, Costco had a slight edge over Sam's Club. It earned its high rating on the strength of its low prices. Eighty-nine percent of those surveyed said mattress prices at Costco were very good or excellent (84 percent gave similar praise to Sam's prices). Overall, readers had few gripes; 70 percent said the transaction went smoothly.

For more information

CR Poll: How did you sleep last night?

Trouble falling asleep, difficulty staying asleep, and awakening too early afflict a lot of Americans these days. Fifty percent of those we asked about their most recent night of sleep reported those problems, and for many, they occur repeatedly.

CR Poll: Economy isn't hurting Americans' sex lives

The economic crisis hasn't affected one leading indicator: Our sex lives. That's one finding from a nationally representative sample of 1,000 adults ages 18 to 75 conducted by the Consumer Reports National Research Center in January 2009.