Roofing Ratings
Choose the best roofing to prevent water damage and stay on budget. Our testing of asphalt shingles and metal roofing includes comprehensive evaluations to help you compare the best options for your home.
View our ratings and reviews and browse our buying guide to find the best roofing.
Asphalt Shingles (18)
The Overall Scores for asphalt shingles are based on performance in our lab tests, with strength more heavily weighted. Overall Scores also include test results for impact, nailing, weight, and wind.
. . .Metal Roofing (6)
The Overall Scores for metal roofing are based on performance in our lab tests and include test results for corrosion, impact, strength, and wind. Our evaluations also assess fire protection.
. . .
Recently Tested Roofing
More From Consumer Reports
How to Get Tax Credits for Home Energy and Efficiency Upgrades Before They Expire
You can earn thousands in federal tax credits for investments made in insulation, solar panels, and heat pumps, but only through the end of 2025
Best Solar Panels of 2025
Choosing the right ones will ensure that they produce plenty of electricity, even in extreme heat or on cloudy days
Best Video Doorbell Cameras Without a Subscription
These highly rated doorbells from Aqara, Eufy, Lorex, Reolink, and TP-Link store recordings locally, which can keep them private and save you money
Best Replacement Windows of 2025
CR's wind- and rain-resistance tests reveal top performers from American Craftsman, Andersen, Jeld-Wen, Marvin, Pella, Preservation, and Reliabilt
Best Weather Stripping and Window Sealing Tapes
Window sealing and weather stripping tapes are a low-cost option for keeping drafts out of your home. And they require minimal effort to install.