Are Smart Thermostats Worth It?
They can often pay for themselves through savings on your cooling and heating cooling bills, but there are exceptions
Smart thermostats have been widely available for more than a decade now, and the consensus is clear: Yes, smart thermostats can be a worthwhile upgrade for many heating and cooling systems, trimming your utility bills while keeping your home comfortable.
If a thermostat can connect to WiFi (or Z-Wave, a smart-home-specific wireless standard), we consider it “smart.” Consumer Reports has tested dozens of smart thermostats in our lab, and currently, our ratings have 50 models. They range from basic models that simply let you adjust the temperature from an app through high-end models from the popular Google Nest and Ecobee lines that try to learn your habits and routines to save you money on energy while keeping your home at a desirable temperature. CR members can see our full ratings based on their automation features, manual controls, and more. (We also have ratings for programmable thermostats.)
Here, we’ll dive into how smart thermostats help optimize your home’s heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) system—or not, because some households don’t gain much by switching to one.
How Smart Thermostats Might Save You Money
There is good evidence that smart thermostats can help most users save money. According to real-world data gathered by the Environmental Protection Agency, smart thermostats that meet Energy Star criteria save users an average of 8 percent on their utility bills. Another study, in which smart thermostats were installed in low-income, multifamily housing, found a similar savings rate. That’s about $50 per year, though the savings might be greater in places with frigid winters, brutal summers, or high energy prices. On the flip side, you might save less if you live in a temperate climate, or if your energy bill is already low.
The secret to the energy savings is pretty simple: Smart thermostats turn off the heat and AC more often than regular thermostats, without sacrificing comfort.
Regular programmable thermostats (without WiFi or smartphone apps) have been able to do this for decades. But their button- (or touch-screen-based) scheduling interfaces tend to be cumbersome, and research estimates that about 40 to 70 percent of programmable thermostat users don’t take advantage of these features. The app-based interfaces for smart thermostats are much easier to use, which likely contributes to the real-world energy savings that they achieve.
At the high end of the category, so-called “learning” thermostats try to automatically set a heating and cooling schedule based on when you tend to be home, and how you’ve used the thermostat over time. This feature is also heavily weighted in our product ratings, according to CR’s Galeotafiore.
Smart thermostats often integrate a few other strategies and features, including reports on how often your system runs, or some nudgy messages about saving energy by choosing milder temperatures. Many models also remind you to replace your HVAC filter, too (usually every three months). Finally, some models can connect to programs that allow your utility company to adjust the thermostat settings in exchange for discounts or incentives.
At the very least, if you don’t use motion sensors, geo-fencing, learning algorithms, or even basic scheduling, you’ll still be able to turn your thermostat off from an app on your phone, which can be a big energy-saver if you forget to do it manually before you leave on a long trip.
Keeping Comfortable With a Smart Thermostat
While many energy-conserving tips and techniques require some level of discomfort or sacrifice, smart thermostats can save energy while maintaining or even improving the comfort in your home.
For example, in a June 2021 nationally representative survey (PDF) of 2,280 U.S. adults, Consumer Reports found that people who own smart thermostats kept their AC set to the same temperature on average—72° F—as people who had regular programmable thermostats or manual thermostats. Essentially, those who use smart thermostats get to enjoy the same comforts from their AC while they’re home while still saving more energy on average while they’re away, thanks to automation and ease of use.
Some smart thermostats also work with remote temperature sensors that can help you get the right temperatures in the right rooms at the right time. If your main thermostat is on the first floor but you spend most of your day working in a second-floor home office that runs warm, you can pop a remote sensor on your desk so that the AC kicks in as needed—and before you sweat through your shirt. These sensors can’t fix all the problems of an unbalanced HVAC system, and could actually increase your energy bills by running the system more often, but it’s an option to consider.
And the simple ability to turn on your HVAC system from your smartphone can be a boon for comfort, too. If you’re coming back from a long trip and the thermostat has been turned way down, you can set it to your normal temperature from the tarmac or the interstate an hour or two before you get home, so it’ll feel comfortable when you arrive.
When a Smart Thermostat Isn't Worth It
Some people might find that a simpler thermostat suits their needs better than a higher-end model with automation. People who understand and appreciate how smart thermostats work—essentially letting their house get warmer or colder sometimes—tend to be satisfied with them, according to Bryan Orr, founder and owner of HVACRSchool.com and president of Kalos Services in Clermont, Fla. “But if the client doesn’t understand it, then they don’t tend to value it,” he adds. He says that even some of his nerdier clients still sometimes find themselves puzzled by the behaviors of learning algorithms on higher-end smart thermostats.
If you’re worried that a fancy-pants smart thermostat might get on your nerves, you can use one of the many relatively simple smart thermostats that connect to WiFi for remote control but don’t bother with learning algorithms or occupancy sensors.
In some homes, a smart thermostat simply won’t do much to save energy or improve your comfort, especially if you’ve already picked off all the low-hanging fruit of energy conservation.
For example, if you already have a “regular” programmable thermostat that you’ve set up with scheduled heating and cooling periods, a smart thermostat may not save much additional energy.
Homes that are occupied most of the time on most days will see smaller savings because there won’t be as many opportunities for the empty-house energy-conserving modes to kick in.
In temperate climates, where energy use and utility bills are naturally lower, a smart thermostat will save less money than average, and certainly less than in places with very hot summers and frigid winters, particularly if they also have high energy costs. It should still trim your costs by about 8 percent on average, but that’s 8 percent of a relatively low number in the first place.
Modern variable-speed air conditioners and especially heat pumps are designed to work better and more efficiently when they run constantly at a fixed temperature. So a smart thermostat’s big energy-saving tool—turning off the system periodically—can actually work against that goal. (A simple smart thermostat that doesn’t automatically change your settings could still make sense, though.)
Finally, if you have an older HVAC system without a C-wire (basically a dedicated power line for your HVAC), you’ll need to select a smart thermostat carefully. Many models won’t work without one. C-wire adapters are sometimes available, but they don’t always work well. And even if a smart thermostat can work without a dedicated C-wire, it won’t always work with very basic two-wire, heat-only systems. In our ratings, we indicate which smart thermostats will work with these legacy setups.
Electric baseboard radiators generally won’t work with most smart thermostats, either, because the voltage levels are mismatched. There are exceptions, though CR hasn’t tested them.