Bread Maker Review: Which Ones Rise to the Occasion?
See how models from Breadman, Cuisinart, and Zojirushi compare in Consumer Reports’ tests
Baking homemade bread was all the rage in the early days of the pandemic, and at first, baking supplies like flour and yeast were scarce.
But now they are in ample supply and cooler weather is on the way, so there’s no reason to stop baking. In fact, CR recently reported that some of the healthiest bread is the kind you bake at home.
Not everyone has the knack for kneading a loaf from scratch, so many consumers turn to bread makers. Sales climbed 800 percent in 2020, according to the King Arthur Flour Company. It came as no surprise to Sharon Davis, director of programs at the nonprofit Home Baking Association. “In our opinion, people finally had time to do something they wanted to do anyway,” Davis says.
Today’s bread makers are more versatile than those that became popular 20 years ago, offering a range of settings for pizza dough and gluten-free bread in addition to basic white and whole-wheat bread.
As part of these tests, Casaregola baked basic white bread and whole-wheat bread, choosing from the recipes that come with each model. With bread flour sold out at supermarkets when she tested these bread makers, she used all-purpose flour instead. (She made recipe adjustments for different types of flour.)
Casaregola evaluated how easy the bread makers were to set up and use, how noisy they were during kneading and baking, and whether the loaves of bread looked evenly baked.
Despite the set-it-and-forget-it nature of bread makers, it's possible to botch a loaf. Davis notes that to get the best results from any model, it’s critical to measure the ingredients accurately. “Weighing your ingredients on a digital scale is always more accurate than measuring by volume,” she says. Doing so ensures that you get the right ratio of ingredients, and that makes for a better loaf of bread.
Casaregola's tests revealed some marked differences among these three models. CR members with digital access can check out the results below in our model-by-model ratings and reviews.