Product Reviews

Welcome to Consumer Reports.

We’re so glad to have you as a member. You now have access to benefits that can help you choose right, be safe and stay informed.
Change Vehicle
2019
  • Road Test
  • Predicted Reliability
  • Predicted Owner Satisfaction
2019 BMW Z4 Ratings & Reliability
The BMW Z4 roadster returns after a three-year hiatus with a soft top, a sportier character, up-to-date advanced safety features, and improved fuel economy. The base 2.0-liter turbo Z4 delivers punchy acceleration and an invigorating exhaust sound. The eight-speed automatic shifts with authority. No manual is available. Its handling is super nimble, but it has an incessantly stiff and choppy ride. The powered soft top can open and close in just 11 seconds, and can be done on the move up to 31 mph. It can also be opened or closed remotely, using the key fob. There is minimal wind buffeting inside with the windows up. The iDrive control system takes some time to master, but it proves intuitive with experience. It has Apple CarPlay compatibility, but it requires a subscription after the first year. All Z4s are equipped with forward collision warning with pedestrian detection, automatic emergency braking, and lane departure warning.
2009-2017
2009 Redesign Year
BMW Z4 2016
The second generation of the Z4 was introduced with a retractable hardtop replacing the cloth top of the previous iteration. This generation also marked the end of the Z4 coupe and the Z4M. Overall, this BMW falls short on the fun-to-drive leader board. Handling is capable and secure, but lacks the tactile feedback and thrill potential a driving enthusiast craves. The bowstring-taut ride is almost jarring at times and the cabin, though well finished, is a snug fit for folks of even average girth. Standard safety equipment includes antilock brakes; brake assist and electronic stability control, along with rollover protection from roll bars behind the head restraints.
Average Retail Price Trade-in Price Reliability Verdict Owner Satisfaction View Local Inventory
2017 NA NA
2016 $25,700 - $32,800 $22,085 - $28,585
2015 $22,150 - $28,150 $18,720 - $24,220
2014 $19,225 - $24,075 $15,600 - $20,350
2013 $16,925 - $20,675 $12,780 - $17,180
2012 $14,375 - $18,750 $10,480 - $14,480
2011 $13,825 - $17,625 $9,930 - $13,330
2010 $12,675 - $14,675 $8,880 - $10,630
2009 $11,625 - $13,375 $7,925 - $9,475
2003-2008
2003 Redesign Year
BMW Z4 2008
The Z4 arrived for 2003 with slightly more interior room, as well as a choice of two six-cylinder engines. While improved over the Z3 (which it replaced) in nearly every way, the Z4 retained the original car's choppy ride. Plus, it isn't very agile, partly because the steering is imprecise and non-linear. The one-touch power top is very convenient. Both of the available 3.0-liter six-cylinders are strong, and the M coupe and roadster use an even more powerful 3.2-liter that makes 330 hp.
Average Retail Price Trade-in Price Reliability Verdict Owner Satisfaction View Local Inventory
2008 $8,225 - $17,625 $4,920 - $13,305
2007 $7,375 - $16,600 $4,160 - $12,360
2006 $6,700 - $15,575 $3,560 - $11,455
2005 $5,975 - $6,250 $2,885 - $3,135
2004 $5,750 - $6,025 $2,680 - $2,930
2003 $5,575 - $5,875 $2,530 - $2,780