Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate
Membership Icon

Non-member Version

Unlock Consumer Report’s ratings and test results today.

Become a Member

2026 Ford Mustang Mach-E vs. 2026 Tesla Model Y Comparison

See how the 2026 Ford Mustang Mach-E and 2026 Tesla Model Y performed in our rigorous, independent road tests. Our experts evaluate hundreds of vehicles annually at our 327-acre testing facility, putting each model through over 50 data-driven assessments—including braking, emergency handling, fuel economy, and cabin noise. Review our side-by-side comparison of tested specifications, real-world fuel efficiency, and crash-test safety ratings to see which is the best for reliability, performance, and more.

Comparing 2 Models

Mustang Mach-E 2026

$37,795 - $53,395

All Test Results

Model Y 2026

Electric SUVs

2026 Tesla Model Y

$39,990 - $59,990

All Test Results
Membership Lock Icon

Unlock Consumer Report's Ratings and Test Results

CR membership is here to help you buy smarter, own with confidence, and save every day—so you can spend your hard-earned money on cars and products that really work and are proven to last.


About
About
The Mach-E is Ford's first designed-from-the-ground-up EV. This five-passenger SUV has useful cargo room and is available with all-wheel drive. The extended-range battery version, equipped with all-wheel drive, has an EPA-estimated range of 300 miles...
 
The freshened Model Y SUV implements the same changes we saw in the revamped Model 3 sedan: A more compliant ride (though it’s still quite firm), acoustic glass for a quieter cabin, upgraded interior materials, and an 8-inch rear touchscreen. Like th...
Highs
Highs
Green Checkmark Icon Acceleration
Green Checkmark Icon Handling
Green Checkmark Icon Quietness
 
Green Checkmark Icon Quick acceleration
Green Checkmark Icon Agile handling
Green Checkmark Icon Comfortable front seats
Green Checkmark Icon Seamless public charging at Tesla superchargers
Lows
Lows
Red 'X' Icon Fussy door handles
Red 'X' Icon Controls
 
Red 'X' Icon Extremely distracting controls
Red 'X' Icon Wimpy A/C
Red 'X' Icon No Android Auto or Apple CarPlay
Road Test Score
Road Test Score
/ 100
 
/ 100
Reliability
Reliability
/ 100
 
/ 100
Owner Satisfaction
Owner Satisfaction
/ 100
 
/ 100

Overview

Body Styles
Body Styles

4-door SUV

 

4-door SUV

Trim Lines
Trim Lines

GT, Premium, Select, Rally

 

Standard, Long Range, Performance, Premium

Base Price Range
Base Price Range

$37,795 - $53,395

 

$39,990 - $59,990

Drive Wheels
Drive Wheels

AWD, RWD

 

AWD, RWD

Seating Capacity
Seating Capacity

2 Front, 3 Rear

 

2 Front, 3 Rear

Engines/Motors
Engines/Motors

electric (325 hp); electric (365 hp); electric (480 hp); electric (290 hp); electric (264 hp)

 

electric (384 hp); electric (456 hp); electric (295 hp)

Transmissions Available
Transmissions Available

1-speed Direct

 

1-speed Direct

Performance

Comfort & Convenience

Fuel Economy & Range

Vehicle Safety

Specification

Warranty

Membership Lock Icon

Unlock Consumer Report's Ratings and Test Results

CR membership is here to help you buy smarter, own with confidence, and save every day—so you can spend your hard-earned money on cars and products that really work and are proven to last.

130+

researchers, engineers, and testing experts

89 years

of fighting for what's right

5M

members strong

Add Another Model

cr-trademark

Auto Test Center

Precision testing comes standard at our 327-acre auto test center.

TESTING LIKE NOBODY ELSE

50+

tests are conducted on every car we buy.

PERFORMANCE TESTING

6

miles of track for testing acceleration, ride, handling, braking, and advanced driver assist systems.

TIRE TESTING

400

tires tested a year for all-weather grip and rolling resistance.