Roofing Ratings
Choose the best roofing to prevent water damage and stay on budget. Our testing of asphalt shingles and metal roofing includes comprehensive evaluations to help you compare the best options for your home.
View our ratings and reviews and browse our buying guide to find the best roofing.
Asphalt Shingles (18)
The Overall Scores for asphalt shingles are based on performance in our lab tests, with strength more heavily weighted. Overall Scores also include test results for impact, nailing, weight, and wind.
. . .Metal Roofing (6)
The Overall Scores for metal roofing are based on performance in our lab tests and include test results for corrosion, impact, strength, and wind. Our evaluations also assess fire protection.
. . .
Recently Tested Roofing
More From Consumer Reports
5 Essential Products to Help Weather a Winter Storm
Forget hot cocoa and a blanket—these products, from generators to snow blowers to smoke detectors, could save your life in a serious snowstorm
12 Best Portable Generators of 2026, Lab-Tested and Reviewed
We tested traditional and inverter generators from brands including Champion, Generac, and Predator to make sure you’ll be powered up during an outage
Best Deals on Healthy-Home Essentials
A healthy lifestyle starts with a healthy home, including top-rated home, tech, and fitness gear
5 Ways to Stay Warm During a Winter Power Outage
We've gathered expert tips on staying warm and safe at home during a major winter storm, from sealing leaks to buying and running a generator
How to Prevent Your Pipes From Freezing and Bursting
A burst pipe can cost you thousands of dollars, but a simple and inexpensive fix can protect your pipes in freezing temperatures