While you might have shed a tear at the last farm fresh tomato of the summer, don't despair: This time of year there are plenty of healthy, tasty fall foods to enjoy, too. And with citrus, potatoes, squash, and many more healthy fall foods available, you can’t go wrong—for your body and your palate—no matter which ones you pick.

Still, when you’re standing in the supermarket produce aisle you can’t help but wonder if between similar fall foods one has a nutritional edge over the other. We’ve put six fall food pairs up against each other to find out.  (Read our special report on pesticides in produce.)

White Potatoes vs. Sweet Potatoes

Go for: Sweet Potatoes
Both spuds supply potassium, a mineral that blunts the impact of sodium on your blood pressure, and white potatoes pack a quarter of your daily need of vitamin C. But if you have to choose one, go with the orange option.

Being “sweet” doesn’t make them significantly higher in carbohydrates or sugars than white potatoes, says Maxine Siegel, R.D., who heads Consumer Reports’ food lab (one small 4 oz white potato has 20 grams of carbs and 0.93 grams sugars, while the same size sweet potato has 23 g of carbs and 4.7 grams of sugars).

And the nutrients you get in exchange are well worthwhile—one serving provides 12 percent of your daily fiber needs and enough carotenoids to supply more than three times your daily dose of vitamin A.

Acorn Squash vs. Butternut Squash

Go for: Acorn Squash
In the closest race since Election Day, acorn squash is the champion in this showdown.

It edges out butternut squash in terms of fiber, magnesium, potassium, thiamin, and vitamin B6. Butternut is higher in vision-protecting vitamin A in the form of beta carotene and other carotenoids (supplying 76 percent of your daily need per cup vs. 17.5 percent for acorn) and slightly lower in calories (82 vs. 115 per cup) and carbs.

Still, the overall nutritional extras you get from acorn squash make the trade worthy. Just be sure to choose either of these superstar veggies over low-cal spaghetti squash—its texture and flavor won’t work the same way in recipes, and eating it won’t add as much nutritionally to your diet. 

Dried Figs vs. Dried Dates

Go for: Either
Both types of  “nature’s candy” make for a super selection. Figs do contain a little more of two crucial minerals: Bone-building calcium and iron, nutrients that can be tough to come by for vegans and others who don’t eat much dairy or meat. But their fiber and calorie counts are similar. Chop either and use as a sweet addition to salads and muffins, or stuff with soft cheese as a salty/sweet snack. 

Walnuts vs. Chestnuts

Go For: Walnuts
Low in fat and calories, chestnuts are not your typical nut. With only about a third of the calories, they outpace walnuts if weight loss is your goal. However, chestnuts have none of the omega 3 fats that make walnuts a heart-healthy pick. “Walnuts are rich in alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), a plant-based omega-3 that has been shown to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease,” says Siegel.

Red Grapes vs. Green Grapes

Go For: Red Grapes
If you’ve heard about the heart-health benefits of red wine, then it should come as no surprise that red grapes also surpass their less colorful counterparts. They contain heart-health booster resveratrol as well as health-promoting anthocyanin pigments, says Jean-Xavier Guinard, Ph.D., Food Scientist at UC Davis.

Oranges vs. Red Grapefruit

Go For: Either
In the citrus showdown, both fruits have similar amounts of calories, magnesium, and potassium. Oranges have the edge in fiber, folate, and thiamin and vitamin C (78 percent of your daily need in one medium orange compared to 53 percent in 1/2 grapefruit). But red grapefruit is one of the few foods that supply the cancer-fighting antioxidant lycopene and it has more beta carotene.