The Best Way to Cook a Turkey

Whether you opt for a fresh or frozen turkey, allow 1 pound per person. That provides each guest with three-quarters of a pound of meat, according to the Department of Agriculture­, and leaves some for leftovers. If you’re hosting a crowd, rather than serving one large turkey, consider cooking two smaller ones, or a whole turkey and a turkey breast. A very large bird can be harder to handle and takes longer to cook.

If you buy a frozen bird, plan to thaw it in a refrigerator set to 37° F for 24 hours for each 4 to 5 pounds of meat. “A 16-pound turkey will take about four to five days to thaw in the fridge,” says Sana Mujahid, PhD, manager of food safety research and testing at Consumer Reports. “Leave the turkey in its original wrapper and put it on a tray on the bottom shelf of the refrigerator. As it thaws, some water and juice could leak out of the plastic wrapping, and you don’t want that to get all over the fridge, spreading bacteria onto surfaces and other foods.” It’s safe to leave a thawed turkey in the fridge for a day or two before cooking.

“You can’t wash off bacteria with water, and rinsing out the turkey risks splashing its juices all over the sink,” Mujahid says. Instead, open the plastic wrap carefully and drain any liquid into the sink before discarding the wrapper. Pat the turkey dry, inside and out, with paper towels. Wash your hands and any utensils, using hot water and soap.

The safest way to cook stuffing is outside of the turkey. Stuffing can absorb the juices from the raw turkey, and if it doesn’t get hot enough (165° F), you and your guests could be susceptible to food poisoning. And cooking the bird until the stuffing is safe will likely lead to overcooked meat.

Using a roasting rack allows hot air to circulate around the turkey, which results in a more even roast. If you don’t have one, you don’t need to rush out to buy one, says Amy Keating RD, a Consumer Reports nutritionist. All you want to do is raise the bottom of the turkey from the roasting pan. You can use a baking cooling rack. Or make your own rack by laying carrots across the bottom of the pan or scrunching aluminum foil into a log shape and then into a circle or spiral and placing the turkey on top of that.

A crispy, golden-brown exterior may be your goal, but it’s the interior temperature that really matters. Too low and you risk food poisoning; too high and your bird may look a lot better than it tastes. Wiggling a drumstick or checking to see if the juices run clear aren’t reliable ways of telling whether a turkey is done. Use a meat thermometer. Note: CR’s tests have found that pop-up thermometers that come with many turkeys aren’t 100 percent accurate.

When you take your turkey’s temperature, remove it from the oven and close the oven door to keep the heat inside in case you need to roast it longer. Insert an instant-read meat thermometer into the innermost part of the thigh and wing (not a drumstick), pushing it in about 2 inches and making sure you don’t hit a bone. Then check the thickest part of a breast, keeping the thermometer horizontal as you insert the probe. The temperature should reach 165° F in both areas for safety.

When the turkey has reached 165° F, remove it from the oven and let it rest, loosely covered, for at least 20 minutes to let the juices redistribute into the meat, Keating says. “That’s when you can make the gravy and finish up last-minute dishes.” Don’t let the cooked bird sit unrefrigerated for more than 2 hours, however. Any bacteria that may be present could multiply to harmful levels if the turkey is left at room temperature longer than that.

You can eat cooked leftover turkey cold, but if you’re reheating it, skip the microwave. Heating turkey in a microwave may dry it out. Warm the meat on the stovetop, adding a little broth or gravy to keep it moist.