Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

Save products you love, products you own and much more!

Save products icon

Other Membership Benefits:

Savings icon Exclusive Deals for Members Best time to buy icon Best Time to Buy Products Recall tracker icon Recall & Safety Alerts TV screen optimizer icon TV Screen Optimizer and more

    Smarter: Would You Get Sick From Not Wearing Enough Clothes?

    Woman outside with purple shirt breathing on her hands to warm them Photo: Getty Images

    This week, I’m examining the idea of whether you will catch a cold if you’re not wearing enough clothes. In an Instagram poll, 24 percent of participants said it was fact, while 76 percent said it was fiction, but who is right?

    Also in this issue: Is age or mileage more important when you’re buying a used car, and the best butters for every occasion.


    THE BIG STORY:

    ‘Gesundheit’

    It is, I regret to inform you, cold season. It is the season of sniffling and congestion and rubbing your nose raw. It is that dreaded period when you are forced to play the game of “is this COVID-19, the flu, or a cold?” whenever you feel unwell.

    It is also that time of the year when my grandfather used to tell me whenever I sneezed to wear more layers. “You’ll catch a cold like this,” he would say forebodingly. He was of a generation who believed young people were tempting fate with their wardrobe choices and that the cure-all of all maladies was a good winter jacket.

    But was he right? Will I catch a cold from not wearing enough clothes?

    More From the Smarter Newsletter

    The answer is no, there’s no direct causal connection between the two. The common cold is a wastebasket term for a host of viruses that cause respiratory tract infection symptoms. And the truth is, you “catch” a cold not by exposure to the elements but by exposure to those viruses, says Joshua Septimus, MD, a medical director at the Houston Methodist Primary Care Group in Bellaire, Texas.

    One of the most likely reasons people catch more colds in cold weather months is because they are around more people indoors, which can increase their exposure to germs. Much evidence shows that certain viruses and bacteria are often transmitted through inhalation of droplets or by touching surfaces that an infectious person has touched, and then transmitting the germs to one’s nose, mouth, or eyes, says Pamela Rockwell, DO, a professor of family medicine at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor.

    Another reason could be the dryness of the air. The mucus in our nose and respiratory tract helps trap pathogens we breathe in before they can cause infection. But the relatively low humidity in heated environments and the resulting dryness of the nose lining can make it easier for viruses to invade the body, Pamela says. 

    Okay, but is there no connection at all between exposure to the cold and getting a cold?
    There may be indirect factors at play. Some research suggests cold weather can affect your susceptibility to being infected by respiratory viruses, says Andrew Karaba, MD, PhD, an assistant professor of medicine at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore. In fact, a new study published in The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology found that cold weather can impair the effectiveness of your nose’s innate immune response. 

    And while cold in and of itself does not trigger viral infections, your immune system does function at its peak when your body temperature is well-regulated. So it’s certainly possible that dysregulation of that balance could have an impact, Joshua says.

    So what are the things to do if you want to avoid catching a cold?
    It’s best to avoid touching your eyes, nose, and mouth with unwashed hands because doing that increases the chances of viruses getting into your body and making you sick. And wash your hands often with soap and water for 20 seconds, according to guidelines from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

    Also, try to avoid close contact with people who are sick. And if you’re going to be in a crowded indoor setting, wearing a high-quality mask is helpful, Joshua says.

    Bonus link: Do home remedies for colds, like chicken soup and honey, actually work?


    QUIZ

    Which holiday food is healthier: ham or roast beef?

    (The answer’s at the end of the newsletter.)


    THE GOOD STUFF

    What you should know before you buy a cheap TV: 

    @consumerreports An inexpensive TV is no bargain if the picture quality disappoints you. See ratings and reviews at cr.org/tv #techtok #tv #shoppingtips #tvtech ♬ original sound - Consumer Reports

    And here are the best TVs of 2022 (available to CR members), including a few that cost less than $1,000.


    MUST-READS OF THE WEEK

    🥄 What Is Kefir—and Is It Good for You?
    It’s been around for thousands of years and is good for your gut.

    📦 How to Keep Packages From Being Stolen by Porch Pirates
    And what to do if they do get stolen.

    🧐 Is Age or Mileage More Important When Buying a Used Vehicle?
    It’s an age-old dilemma.

    🧈 Best Butters for Everyday Use and Special Occasions
    And which is better: salted or unsalted?


    LET ME QUICKLY BUST A MYTH FOR YOU

    Here’s a question: Can you buy a self-driving car if you want to?

    The answer is no. There are no fully self-driving cars available to individual buyers today. While half of the car models on sale now offer some form of lane centering assistance and adaptive cruise control, they don’t qualify as “self-driving cars” because the driver is still expected to pay attention. Even Cadillac models that are equipped with GM’s Super Cruise hands-free driving ability have a camera that monitors whether the driver is paying attention. The system eventually disengages if it senses that the driver is not watching the road. 

    The same goes for Tesla cars. Despite offering a high-priced option of features called Full Self-Driving, Tesla cars still aren’t fully autonomous vehicles because they still require a driver to steer, brake, or accelerate as needed.

    Have a question about something that you aren’t sure is myth or fact? Send me a question and it might be featured in Smarter.


    GONNA SLEEP ON THIS

    GIF of Spongebob angrily diving back to sleep

    Source: Nickelodeon/”SpongeBob SquarePants”/Giphy Source: Nickelodeon/”SpongeBob SquarePants”/Giphy

    Today I learned that you can’t judge a sheet by its thread count. Or more precisely, thread count isn’t a reliable indicator of performance.


    QUIZ ANSWER

    If you choose a leaner cut, roast beef is healthier than ham because the latter can be very high in sodium. Also, the nitrates and nitrites in spiral hams can trigger potentially carcinogenic compounds when they interact with protein.

    What about apple pie vs. pumpkin pie? You can read more about which holiday foods are healthier here.


    Owl Icon

    "The cold never bothered me anyway."


    Thanks for reading Smarter! If you want more tips that will make you a little bit smarter, sign up to have the newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every week.



    Pang-Chieh Ho

    Pang-Chieh Ho is a senior content creator at Consumer Reports who writes about the intersections of home products and health. She has been working in the media industry for almost 10 years. Books are her first love, but movies come a close second. You can send tips to her at pangchieh.ho@consumer.org.