Our Favorite Store-Brand Chocolate Ice Cream

This ice cream has a rich, fudgy flavor and subtle nutty notes. The texture is slightly icy and light but not airy.

Good, bittersweet chocolate taste, with notes of caramel. It has a nice thick texture, too, that makes it taste a bit richer than Breyers and other supermarket regular ice creams.

Despite the word "premium" on the label, the calories and fat content of this ice cream are similar to other “regular” ice creams. Our testers like its deep, dark-chocolate flavor. It's a bit sweeter, fudgier, and denser than Breyers.

Mild milk-chocolate ice cream with a slightly airy texture. It contains more additives than the brand name.

Basic chocolate flavor with malty notes and a slightly airy texture. It contains more additives than the brand name.

Milk-chocolate ice cream with a slightly airy texture. It contains more additives than the brand name.

Dense, full, and creamy smooth ice cream with balanced chocolate and milk flavors and subtle nutty and caramel notes.

A win for dark-chocolate lovers, this creamy dessert has a deep, rich flavor, with hints of nuts and coffee. Dense and creamy.

This tastes close to Häagen-Dazs: dense and creamy, with a milk-chocolate flavor and some nutty notes.

The flavor of the chocolate is milder here than in some of the others in this category, and you pick up hints of cherry and malt. Dense texture.

Reminiscent of a dark-chocolate brownie, this one has a rich fudgy flavor and a fairly dense texture.