Roofing Ratings
Choose the best roofing to prevent water damage and stay on budget. Our testing of asphalt shingles and metal roofing includes comprehensive evaluations to help you compare the best options for your home.
View our ratings and reviews and browse our buying guide to find the best roofing.
Asphalt Shingles (18)
The Overall Scores for asphalt shingles are based on performance in our lab tests, with strength more heavily weighted. Overall Scores also include test results for impact, nailing, weight, and wind.
. . .Metal Roofing (6)
The Overall Scores for metal roofing are based on performance in our lab tests and include test results for corrosion, impact, strength, and wind. Our evaluations also assess fire protection.
. . .
Recently Tested Roofing
More From Consumer Reports
10 Best Video Doorbell Cameras of 2025, Lab-Tested and Reviewed
Consumer Reports' tests identify the best models to ward off porch pirates and ding-dong ditchers
10 Best Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Detectors of 2025, Tested and Reviewed
CR's testers say these models from First Alert, Kidde, Siterwell, and Universal Instruments are great at protecting you and your loved ones from harm
16 Best Home Security Cameras of 2025, Lab-Tested and Reviewed
Consumer Reports tests security cameras and doorbell cameras for data privacy, security, video quality, and more
6 Best Floodlight Cameras of 2025, Lab-Tested and Reviewed
These security cameras light up the night and are made by some of the most popular home security brands, including Blink, Eufy, and Lorex
The Eureka J15 Max Ultra Is Not the Wet Spill Zapper It Claims to Be
After a preliminary spin around one of our labs, we were disappointed with this smart device’s not-so-smart reaction to wet spills