Roofing Ratings
Choose the best roofing to prevent water damage and stay on budget. Our testing of asphalt shingles and metal roofing includes comprehensive evaluations to help you compare the best options for your home.
View our ratings and reviews and browse our buying guide to find the best roofing.
Asphalt Shingles (18)
The Overall Scores for asphalt shingles are based on performance in our lab tests, with strength more heavily weighted. Overall Scores also include test results for impact, nailing, weight, and wind.
. . .Metal Roofing (6)
The Overall Scores for metal roofing are based on performance in our lab tests and include test results for corrosion, impact, strength, and wind. Our evaluations also assess fire protection.
. . .
Recently Tested Roofing
More From Consumer Reports
3 Best Indoor Air Quality Monitors of 2026
The best monitors from CR’s tests detect a range of indoor pollutants, and some work automatically with air purifiers
6 Best Whole-House Generators of 2026, Lab-Tested and Reviewed
Home standby generators from companies like Champion, Generac, and Kohler are pricey, but they provide immediate backup power during outages
9 Best Solar Outdoor Lights of 2026, Lab-Tested and Reviewed
We spotlight top-rated solar lights for your walkway and garden from brands like Harbor Breeze and Westinghouse
10 Best Inverter Generators of 2026, Lab-Tested and Reviewed
Top models from Champion, Generac, Honda, Yamaha, and other brands outperform most conventional portable generators
25 of the Worst Products of 2025—and What to Buy Instead
Why should top-rated products get all the attention? Let’s talk about the worst products we tested, including a space heater that leaves you cold and a fridge with hot spots