Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

CR Staffers' Favorite Analog Activities Make for Great Gifts

Tempted to ditch the screen? These tech-free gift ideas will inspire you to unplug and unwind.

When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.

Animation cycles through analog gift ideas Potholder PRO® Loom Kit, Spaghetti!: An Interactive Recipe Book, Lego Woodland Mushrooms, The New Yorker Bodega Cat
1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle, and The Big Book of Wordsearch set against blue satin ribbon. Photo: Scott Meadows/Consumer Reports, Manufacturer

It may be the millennial in me, but the holidays always seem to drum up waves of nostalgia. Whether it’s indulging in a vintage movie marathon or competing in a friendly gingerbread house decorating contest, there’s something about the luxury of taking a beat to relish in the moment and doing it from the cozy corners of my home. 

Leaning into the practice of unplugging and taking things slow, I was inspired by the idea of going analog—even for just an evening. With that in mind, I turned to a handful of my colleagues for their take on the best screen-free, tech-free activities. The best part? Their thoughtful recommendations also make for fantastic gifts.

Shop

Puzzles

Name a better feeling than being gathered around a puzzle on a cold winter’s night. My colleagues appear to share that sentiment—it was the most commonly recommended screen-free activity. Sure, there are seemingly endless options to choose from, but we’re partial to these picks.

Le Puzz Darlin' Jigsaw Puzzle

Le Puzz Darlin' Jigsaw Puzzle

Baby and health reporter Jess Waller loves giving and receiving puzzles, especially ones from Le Puzz. She lauds them for their sturdy construction, having the perfect jigsaw snap, and the ability to withstand multiple completions. “True puzzlers know there’s nothing more frustrating than a low-quality puzzle,” says Waller. Bonus: The mini puzzles make a thoughtful host gift.

Still undecided?
CR's expert guidance and unbiased reviews can help you purchase with confidence.

New York Puzzle Company Bodega Cat

New York Puzzle Company Bodega Cat

We love a New Yorker cover, especially one depicting a classic New York moment. “I received this puzzle for the holidays last year, and it is wonderful,” says senior writer Jodhaira Rodriguez. “[It’s] one of the more difficult puzzles I’ve worked on ever, but it’s beautiful; the pieces are so uniquely shaped, and it is huge.”

Rolife Tipsy Restaurant DIY Miniature House Kit

Rolife Tipsy Restaurant DIY Miniature House Kit

Ally Cooper, who’s a CR food safety and nutrition technician, is also an avid puzzler, specifically those of another dimension. “I love a jigsaw puzzle, but also 3D puzzles (similar to Legos). Unlike a jigsaw puzzle, which you typically return to the box, this creates a cute piece of decor,” she says. Cooper’s puzzle of choice is this miniature kit depicting a cozy cafe scene. 

Lego Woodland Mushroom

Lego Woodland Mushroom

For the Lego-lover who’s ready to take things to the next level, this botanically themed set is sure to please. Once complete, display your work and relish the funky, woodland-inspired scene.

Books and Brain Teasers

Joel Fagliano & New York Times Games Puzzle Mania!: Wordle, Connections, Spelling Bee, Minis and More!

Joel Fagliano & New York Times Games Puzzle Mania!: Wordle, Connections, Spelling Bee, Minis and More!

If your idea of a good time is getting cozy with a crossword puzzle in hand, you’ve come to the right place. “I count down the days every December until the release of NYT’s giant Puzzlemania pullout section in the Sunday paper, but now you can get your puzzle fix year-round,” says Waller. This joyful book features a compilation of crosswords, trivia, and other iconic games from The New York Times such as Wordle and Connections. “The Puzzlemania book looks great on your coffee table and is a perfect winter-break activity,” adds Waller. 

Cottage Door Press The Big Book of Wordsearch

Cottage Door Press The Big Book of Wordsearch

We’ll tackle a word search any day of the week, but one that doubles as a learning opportunity earns a major plus in our books. This tome of puzzles is categorized by themes ranging from pop culture to history, geography, and more. “I love word searches and have been doing puzzles from this book when I need a break from staring at a screen,” says Rodriguez. “This book is the perfect size for taking on the go. It’s my favorite part of my very own little brain stack.”

Phaidon "Spaghetti!: An Interactive Recipe Book" by Lotta Nieminen

Phaidon "Spaghetti!: An Interactive Recipe Book" by Lotta Nieminen

Hunkering down with a good book is always a good time, regardless of your age. “These bright, modern board books are endlessly engaging and interactive, and make the best baby gifts,” says Waller, who’s given these countless times to friends with new babies. “I’ve found that the graphic illustrations and fun wordplay mean you won’t get tired of reading them (on repeat).”

Waller also recommends "My First Book of Patterns" by Bobby George and June George, available for $12 at Amazon and Target.

Macmillan Publishers "Beautyland" by Marie-Helene Bertino

Macmillan Publishers "Beautyland" by Marie-Helene Bertino

For more advanced reading levels, Rodriguez recommends “Beautyland” by Marie-Helene Bertino. “I could share a list pages long of great books I’ve read this year, but here’s my No. 1 read: A beautiful story that I have not stopped thinking about since I first read it way back in February of this year.”

Games and Crafts

Beezen Candle Beeswax Candle Making Kit – Natural Beeswax Sheets with Cotton Wick

Beezen Candle Beeswax Candle Making Kit – Natural Beeswax Sheets with Cotton Wick

A screen-free activity that can turn into a gift is a no-brainer. Waller loves these beeswax candle rolling kits, which are especially great for kids. “Burning beeswax candles is basically my whole raison d’etre in the winter,” she says. “I made rolled beeswax candles with my kids to give as teacher gifts last year, and they were a hit! Tied up with a ribbon, they make for a beautiful and practical present. And the beeswax smells so heavenly when it burns.”

WS Game Company Bookshelf Games: The Game of Life

WS Game Company Bookshelf Games: The Game of Life

The holidays wouldn’t be the same without gathering around a board game. Between Clue, Monopoly, and Scrabble, the choices are endless. My personal favorite is The Game of Life, and this version from WS Game Company is the latest addition to my collection. I love that it’s discreet and compact enough to be displayed on my bookshelf, without compromising what really matters—the game itself. 

Home Science Tools Small Sunprint Kit

Home Science Tools Small Sunprint Kit

Calling all crafters. Here’s to an old-school activity that encourages a little outdoor time. “These nostalgic cyanotype printing kits use just sun and water to make beautiful artwork,” says Waller. “Paired with a nature walk, it’s a perfect winter day activity.”

Friendly Loom Potholder PRO Loom Kit

Friendly Loom Potholder PRO Loom Kit

CR’s senior major gifts officer, Elizabeth Lucy, is a big fan of this portable loom kit. It makes two 8x8-inch potholders in a vibrant colorway and comes complete with everything you’ll need to weave the pieces. “All my long car rides are so much better now,” says Lucy. 


Anna Kocharian

Anna Kocharian is a shopping editor at Consumer Reports who focuses on home, organization, and the consumer marketplace. She previously covered interior design, product reviews, and market trends as the digital editor of Domino. Anna has over a decade of experience in lifestyle journalism and has written extensively on the subject matter for publications including Apartment Therapy, Food52, and more. She currently resides in New York City.