Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

Which iPhone Should You Buy?

From the iPhone 17 and slim iPhone Air to the budget iPhone 17e, there are lots of smart options. Here's how to choose the best one for you.

When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.

iPhone 17 Pro, iPhone Air and iPhone 17.
Apple's latest line of phones includes (clockwise from left) the iPhone 17 Pro, iPhone Air, and iPhone 17.
Photos: Apple

Fans of the iPhone now have a wealth of choices when looking for a new device, but what differentiates Apple’s highest-end option from its budget-friendly one isn’t always clear.

It gets even more complicated if you consider an older, refurbished iPhone, too. You’re left comparing a dozen or more options and a slew of similar-sounding specs. But we can help you with that.

More on Apple Gear

Apple currently offers the flagship iPhone 17 line (which includes the iPhone 17, the slimmer iPhone Air, and two premium models: the 17 Pro and 17 Pro Max), but the company also sells the new budget-friendly iPhone 17e, plus the iPhone 16 and the 16 Plus.

So how do you decide which one is the best for you?

Here are a few key factors to consider before you pull out your credit card.

First, there’s your budget. If you’re buying new, you can pay as little as $599 for the iPhone 17e and as much as $1,999 for the jumbo iPhone 17 Pro Max with 2 terabytes of storage space.

But the size of the phone and the way you plan to use it should also guide your decision.

Do you want the jumbo, 6.9-inch screen on the 17 Pro Max or the 17e’s 6.1-inch screen, which is easier to use with one hand? How crucial is all-day battery life or having an optical telephoto lens for zoom shots? Is storage space a top priority—or do you house everything in the cloud anyway?

Here’s a closer look at Apple’s iPhone options listed by size and price, as marked by Apple. The table at the bottom of the page summarizes the key features of each model.

Note that the iPhone 16 Pro and 16 Pro Max are no longer available directly from Apple. Neither are the models in the iPhone 14 and 15 lines. But you can still find them at other retailers, often in refurbished form. Some are still listed in our smartphone ratings (for CR members) for side-by-side comparisons.

6.1-Inch iPhone 17e, $599

If you want Apple’s most budget-friendly option, the new iPhone 17e is for you. The model is heading to our labs for testing, but the previous generation iPhone 16e earned impressive scores (see below). The 17e has a 6.1-inch display, making it the smallest option in the iPhone 17 line. It also comes in a new pink shade, in addition to the standard black and white editions.

The 17e runs on Apple’s A19 chip, which allows for the extra processing power needed for Apple’s AI features. (All iPhone models currently sold by Apple support Apple Intelligence.) If you judge by the 16e’s performance, you can expect the 17e to tackle nearly any task, including FaceTiming with a friend and navigating with GPS, without much lag. The 17e also starts with 256 gigabytes of storage—a bump up from 128 gigabytes on the 16e at the same price.

The 17e has just one 48-megapixel rear camera. That means it’s less versatile than the multilens setups on other iPhone models, which allow for ultrawide shots at 0.5x zoom or optical zoom for crisper long-range shots. While our testers have yet to rate the 17e’s camera system (check back soon for results), you may want to look at other models if a premium camera is important to you.

The 17e offers standard USB-C charging and is also compatible with wireless charging. You can expect all-day battery life, Apple says. The 16e lasts 37.5 hours per charge, according to our testing.

If you’re worried about Apple’s budget model being less durable, have no fear: The 16e aced our scratch-resistance and water-intrusion tests and withstood 100 drops in our tumbler with no significant dents. Our experts will know soon whether the 17e fares the same.

6.3-Inch iPhone 17, $799, or 6.1-Inch iPhone 16, $699

If you want a reasonably sized iPhone with a great camera, the standard iPhone line is where to look. These models cost $300 less than their Pro counterparts, which offer the most premium features and a triple-rear camera setup, but they still perform very well in our tests where it matters.

The iPhone 17 has a larger 6.3-inch OLED display that offers excellent color and clarity. It features a dual-rear camera system with a 48-megapixel main rear camera and a 48-megapixel ultrawide that outperforms the previous-generation iPhone 16’s camera, according to our latest testing. It’s not quite as impressive as the Pro cameras, but it beats the single rear camera on the iPhone 16e or iPhone Air.

The iPhone 17 comes equipped with Apple’s A19 chip, which the company says helps facilitate an increasing number of generative Apple Intelligence features. And it comes with a few other modest upgrades, like a smoother 120-hertz refresh rate and 256 gigabytes of starting storage.

The iPhone 17 lasts 32.5 hours per charge and receives the highest possible durability score in our ratings, surviving dozens of drops in CR’s tumbler without breaking.

6.5-Inch iPhone Air, $999

If you hate the tug of a heavy device in your jacket pocket, the iPhone Air might be a great fit. This model—which subs in for the Plus model in the latest iPhone line—has a large 6.5-inch ProMotion display and a titanium frame, but it’s the thinnest-ever iPhone, measuring just 5.6 millimeters thick. Despite its petite size, you don’t have to fret about its fragility: It receives a stellar durability score, surviving 100 drops in CR’s tumbler and immersion in water. It also holds up well to our scratch-resistance testing.

The iPhone Air has the more powerful A19 Pro chip and a faster 120-hertz refresh rate for smoother scrolling. CR’s testing shows that the camera system isn’t quite as impressive as that on the Pro models—it has only a single 48-megapixel main rear camera—but you do get the improved 18-megapixel front-facing camera available across the iPhone 17 line.

According to our testing, the iPhone Air offers a reasonable 29.5 hours of use on a single charge, but it’s still the worst performer in terms of battery life across the iPhone 17 line.

Overall, the iPhone Air is worth considering if you love the super-slim design—and you don’t mind taking a slight hit on battery life and camera performance.

6.3-Inch iPhone 17 Pro, $1,099, or 16 Pro

Willing to spend a little more for Apple’s latest hardware, but without the jumbo-sized display? The 6.3-inch iPhone 17 Pro has a more powerful A19 Pro chip that improves performance, even for the increasing number of generative AI features.

The 17 Pro’s triple-rear camera system is particularly impressive, earning one of the highest-ever camera scores in our labs. The model has a 48-megapixel main rear camera, a 48-megapixel ultrawide, and a new 48-megapixel telephoto, as well as a new selfie camera that can more dynamically shift to landscape mode without having to turn the phone.

The 17 Pro has the same 120-hertz high refresh rate (good for gameplay and smoother scrolling) as its siblings. It also features a few other iterative upgrades, like a more crack-resistant ceramic shield on the back of the phone. (The model indeed earns the highest possible rating for durability in our testing.)

The 17 Pro’s battery life is 34 hours on a single charge—a couple of hours longer than the iPhone 17 base model but not as long as the larger iPhone 17 Pro Max, which lasts 43 hours on a single charge.

Overall, the 17 Pro looks to be the choice if you want the latest tech and best camera on a device you can more comfortably use with one hand.

6.9-Inch iPhone 17 Pro Max, $1,199, or 16 Pro Max

This is the biggest and best model that Apple has to offer. With the iPhone 17 Pro Max, you get a large 6.9-inch display with a smooth 120-hertz refresh rate, the more powerful A19 Pro chip, and Apple’s most versatile Pro camera system. The 17 Pro Max also offers a 2-terabyte storage option.

The 17 Pro Max has the same triple-rear camera available on the 17 Pro, which includes a 48-megapixel main rear camera, a 48-megapixel ultrawide camera, and a new 48-megapixel telephoto, as well as the improved selfie camera featured across the iPhone 17 line. It’s one of the most impressive camera systems we’ve tested on a smartphone to date.

If you’re willing to spend more for the largest display and most impressive camera, the Pro Max is the model for you.

iPhone Models by the Numbers

The table below spotlights the major differences among the phones. (If you’re reading this article on a smartphone, we recommend that you rotate the phone to landscape mode for a better view.)

iPhone Model,
Starting Price
Display SizeMain CameraStorage Options
iPhone 16, $6996.1 inches48MP wide-angle, ultrawide-angle, and 2x camera128GB, 256GB, 512GB
iPhone 16 Plus, $7996.7 inches48MP wide-angle, ultrawide-angle, and 2x camera128GB, 256GB, 512GB
iPhone 16 Pro (available from third-party retailers)6.3 inches48MP wide-angle, ultrawide-angle, and 5x camera128GB, 256GB, 512GB,
1TB
iPhone 16 Pro Max (available from third-party retailers)6.9 inches48MP wide-angle, ultrawide-angle, and 5x camera256GB, 512GB,
1TB
iPhone 17e, $5996.1 inches48MP wide-angle camera256GB,
512GB
iPhone 17, $7996.3 inches48MP wide-angle, ultrawide-angle, and 2x camera128GB, 256GB, 512GB
iPhone Air, $9996.5 inches48MP wide-angle camera128GB, 256GB, 512GB
iPhone 17 Pro, $1,099 6.3 inches48MP wide-angle, ultrawide-angle, and 5x camera256GB, 512GB,
1TB
iPhone 17 Pro Max, $1,1996.9 inches48MP wide-angle, ultrawide-angle, and 5x camera256GB, 512GB,
1TB,
2TB
@consumerreports

We buy *every* phone we test, including the latest iPhone16e! 🔥 We’ve put it through rigorous testing on battery life, durability, and performance. Tap the link in our bio for the full results. #techtok #iphone #iphone16

♬ original sound - Consumer Reports

Courtney Lindwall

Courtney Lindwall is a writer at Consumer Reports. Since joining CR in 2023, she’s covered the latest on cell phones, smartwatches, and fitness trackers as part of the tech team. Previously, Courtney reported on environmental and climate issues for the Natural Resources Defense Council. She lives in Brooklyn, N.Y.