Face-Off: 2019 Subaru Ascent vs. 2019 Toyota Highlander

Subaru’s all-new midsized SUV takes on the segment stalwart

Subaru Ascent vs. Toyota Highlander

The Toyota Highlander has been among CR’s top-rated SUVs for years—and a nine-time Top Pick—but now it faces a new challenger in the 2019 Subaru Ascent. These two models match up closely, and it’s a hard-fought battle to declare a winner.

There are dozens of midsized, three-row SUVs on the market, but the Highlander has been a Top Pick for so many years because it has consistently delivered good performance, fuel economy, and very good reliability. It’s a well-rounded SUV that’s easy to live with. Toyota introduced an all-new Highlander for 2020.

More Three-row SUV road tests

This isn’t Subaru’s first three-row SUV. It used to sell the Tribeca from 2006 through 2014. It was an okay vehicle, but it couldn’t compete well because of its small second- and third-row seats, underpowered engine, and poor fuel economy. Now that Subaru has a true three-row SUV, the question is, has the automaker learned the lessons of the Tribeca? And can the Ascent unseat the category champ?

We take an in-depth look at these two models by comparing how they fared in CR’s testing and surveys. And we let you know which one climbs to the top.

If you’re a CR member, this article and the list below are already available to you. But if you haven’t signed up, click below and become a member to access this list and all our exclusive ratings and reviews for each vehicle we buy and test. Joining also gives you full access to exclusive ratings for the other products our experts evaluate in several categories, including electronics and home appliances.

Sign up for CR’s Cars email newsletter to be notified when we post our latest road tests. 

The Case for the Subaru Ascent

SUVs Tested
Access Ratings