Product Reviews

Thanks Jennifer. We are looking forward to working with you. We will be in touch

Your account has been created
One of the best vacuums of 2017.

Best Vacuums of 2017

These vacuums really suck, which is exactly why we like them

It’s been a fun year in Consumer Reports’ vacuum labs. Cordless stick vacuums are better than ever and are now crowding out corded stick vacs at major retailers. And robotic vacuums have finally transcended being a novelty item featured in YouTube cat videos to a serious cleaning tool. If the search volume on our website is any indication, robotic vacuums could very well be one of the hottest gifts of the season.

But while the new kids on the block are turning heads, if you want deep cleaning, you’ll still need to rely on your trusty upright or canister vacuum.

And we found plenty of good choices in our tests of full-sized vacuums from such brands as Kenmore, Miele, Dyson, and Hoover, among others.

How We Test Vacuums
To find out how well a vacuum picks up dirt, how much debris it retains, how easy it is to maneuver, and how noisy it is, Consumer Reports puts its vacuum cleaners through a tough set of tests. We embed talc, sand, and pet hair into carpet and then challenge the vacuum to pick it up. We use the same type of litter on bare floors and observe whether the vacuum picks it up or scatters it about. And we maneuver the vacuum around just like you would to make sure it's easy to operate.

Here, then, are the best vacuums of 2017 from each type we test. Drum roll—er, brush roll, please.  

Bagged Upright
Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly 31150

Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly 31150

CR's take: The midpriced Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly 31150 earns top marks on bare floors and scores Excellent for Tool airflow. That means it's exceptionally powerful when used with its attachments, which include a crevice tool, bristle brush, and power roller. On bare floors it captures almost every particle it picks up, keeping them contained in its disposable bag. And it's no slouch at removing embedded dirt from carpet or tackling pet hair, either, although it's a little louder and tougher to handle than some other models of this type. It’s not the cheapest model you’ll find, but this impressive performer is certainly among the best vacuums we tested this year.  

    Bagless Upright
    Dyson Ball Multi Floor 2

    Dyson Ball Multi Floor 2

    CR's take: The Dyson Ball Multi Floor 2 excels at cleaning bare floors and is almost as good at cleaning carpet. It’s also a good choice if you have pets that shed because it cleans up on our pet hair test, earning a top score of Excellent. CR's test engineers found this Dyson to be superb at containing the dust it collects—it scored Excellent for emissions, although that score doesn't account for the mess you may make when emptying the bin into the trash. (That's true of any bagless vacuum.) The Dyson lacks a few features that may be important to you, notably a manual carpet-height adjustment and suction control, which protects your curtains when you’re using the attachments. One last caveat we must share: It’s one of the noisier bagless uprights we tested.

      Bagged Canister
      Miele Complete C3 Marin

      Miele Complete C3 Marin

      CR's take: Our top-performing canister vacuum, the Miele Complete C3 Marin earned perfect marks in almost every test we threw its way. It’s a champ at bare floors and embedded pet hair but also excels at capturing dust particles. Powerful airflow makes its attachments especially effective. It’s also noticeably quieter than many models, earning a rare score of Very Good in CR's noise test. It gets dinged a bit on our Handling test (Good), and that's true of most cannister vacuums, which trail behind you on the end of the suction hose. But at more than $1,000, it may suck a big chunk out of your bank account, too, certainly something to consider before making the splurge. 

        Bagless Canister
        Kenmore 22614

        Kenmore 22614

        CR's take: If you can live without bags, this Kenmore 22614 aced our Bare floors test (Excellent) and was nearly as good at Carpet cleaning (Very Good). It’s also worth a look if you have pets, as it performed superbly on our tests vacuuming up embedded cat hair. You’ll appreciate the capable tool airflow if you use your attachments a lot, and this vacuum is also low on emissions, meaning it retains what it sucks up. The noise level is so-so and the vacuum isn’t as easy to maneuver as other canisters in this class—it scored Fair in CR's Handling test.

          Stick Vacuum (Less Than 6 Pounds)
          Dyson V8 Absolute

          Dyson V8 Absolute

          CR's take: On the surface, it might seem difficult to justify the purchase of a stick vac that costs two or three times what you would spend on a top-rated full-sized vacuum. Though no stick vacuum can fully replace the performance of an upright or a canister, it’s what the Dyson V8 Absolute can do that makes it such a standout in our ratings. It offers exceptionally powerful suction, which helps it earn perfect scores on bare floors, carpets, pet hair, and edges in our tests. It’s also among the quietest of comparable models and runs an impressive 21 minutes on a single battery charge—long enough that you might be surprised at how infrequently you’ll need to lug around a heavier, full-sized model.

            Stick Vacuum (More Than 6 Pounds)
            Bissell Air Ram 1984

            Bissell Air Ram 1984

            CR's take: The cordless Bissell Air Ram 1984 easily sucks up dirt and debris from carpets and bare floors, and even devours embedded pet hair in our test—compacting the collected debris into little bales of dirt stashed in the head of the unit. While it lacks the suction of a full-sized upright or canister, it’s still a vast improvement over the cordless sweepers of yesteryear. In fact, it scored Excellent in most of our tests. Its edge cleaning performance is solid, but lags behind some other stick vacuums because it lacks a crevice tool. Despite that, we’re willing to bet it’ll become your go-to for small spills and everyday messes. It stands upright on its own and has a handle that collapses to fit under pantry shelves. And with a 47-minute runtime, it’s the perfect way to keep floors tidy between deep cleanings. 

              Robotic Vacuum
              Samsung POWERbot SR20H9051 Series

              Samsung POWERbot SR20H9051 Series

              CR's take: After a decade or so of domination by Roomba, Samsung’s Powerbot eked out a win in the battle of the best robotics. It's a category that has seen an onslaught of noteworthy new entrants, including models from premium brands Dyson and Miele. The Powerbot powers through dirt on carpets and bare floors, scoring Excellent in both tests, and even finds its way into tight corners, thanks in part to its rectangular design. It operates quietly enough that it’ll go unnoticed, though it’s hard to resist watching it return home to dock and charge after each intensive 99-minute cleaning session. But even for the sum of $1,000, no robotic vacuum can replace a full-sized upright or canister. It's just that the Powerbot comes closer than any other.

                Hand Vacuum
                Shark Pet Perfect II SV780

                Shark Pet Perfect II SV780

                The Shark Pet Perfect does everything a great hand vacuum should do, in an inexpensive and easy-to-use package. It excels at sweeping small messes from bare floors and easily gets into corners. It runs for a full 19 minutes—longer than you’d need for most small messes—and even comes with a rotating brush roll that helps it tackle pet hair or spot-clean carpets. We also appreciate that the nickel cadmium battery is replaceable, though it takes a full 16 hours to charge. Note that it only scored Good in our Noise test. Still, for an appliance you may only need occasionally, this hand vac is a great way to stretch out more thorough cleanings and tackle such messes as spilled Cheerios on the spot before they spread through your house. 

                  Shopping links are provided by eBay Commerce Network and Amazon, which makes it easy to find the right product from a variety of online retailers. Clicking any of the links will take you to the retailer's website to shop for this product. Please note that Consumer Reports collects fees from both eBay Commerce Network and Amazon for referring users. We use 100% of these fees to fund our testing programs.
                  Paul Hope

                  As a classically trained chef and an enthusiast DIYer, I've always valued having the best tool for a job—whether the task at hand is dicing onions for mirepoix or hanging drywall. When I'm not writing about home products, I can be found putting them to the test in the 1850s farmhouse my wife and I are restoring while raising our two young children.