Hybrids, small turbos often fall short of EPA mileage estimates

Hybrids get great mileage, but some leave their owners disappointed because their window stickers promise better fuel economy than the cars deliver.

We analyzed more than 315 cars and compared the results of our own tests with EPA window stickers. While most cars in our study fell within one or two mpg of their official estimates, two groups stood out as not living up to the claims their window stickers' promise. (See our full report on "The mpg gap.")

Here's what we found:

• The vast majority of hybrids fell short of their EPA estimates in our tests. As a group, hybrids missed their estimates by 10 percent on average. The most egregious were the latest hybrids from Ford and Volkswagen. The Lincoln MKZ Hybrid, rated 45 mpg overall in EPA tests (with identical city and highway ratings), returned just 35 mpg in our tests, a discrepancy of nearly 25 percent.

• The latest wave of cars with small, turbocharged engines also fell short. In our analysis, more than three quarters of cars with these small, turbocharged engines missed their EPA estimates. Some cars fell short of the advertised figure by as much as 15 percent.

These types of cars are much more sensitive to how they're driven, says Mike Duoba, a test engineer with Argonne National Laboratory who works on fuel economy testing. So the old adage about "your mileage may vary" holds doubly true for these types of cars.

Under those conditions, hybrids and cars with turbocharged small engines operate at peak efficiency, delivering excellent fuel economy. But in the real world, where these powertrains have to work much harder to keep up with higher-speed traffic, their fuel economy drops precipitously. That shows up in our testing.

Updates the EPA made to its test procedures in 2008 capture some of this discrepancy with conventional cars, but not the steep drop-off in hybrids and small turbos.

We've discussed our findings with the EPA, and the agency says it is reviewing its tests and considering updating them.

Meanwhile, what should consumers do? Don't write off hybrids, but consider slightly lowering your expectations. Hybrids still get the best mileage of any cars in many popular car types. Among the best is the Toyota Prius, which returned 44 mph overall in our tests (EPA estimates are 50 mpg).

Shoppers should also consider some of the cars that consistently beat their EPA estimates in our analysis: those with manual transmissions or diesel engines. These cars tend to deliver excellent mileage all the time, not just in the city as most hybrids do.

Related:
Tests show Ford Fusion, C-Max hybrids don't live up to 47-mpg claims
EPA finds Hyundai exaggerated fuel economy claims, refunds coming to customers
Consumer Reports finds small turbo engines don't deliver on fuel economy claims

—Eric Evarts