Best Air Fryers of 2019

NuWave, GoWise, Ninja, Farberware, and Elite jockey for top spots in Consumer Reports' ratings

The NuWave 37001 air fryer is shown with a batch of just-made french fries.
Testers made french fries in the NuWave 37001 air fryer to find out whether air-fried food tastes like the real thing.
When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.

Crispy fries without all the oil? That's the golden promise of air fryers, and it probably explains why, in the U.S., about 4 million were sold in just a year. That represents a tenfold increase in two years, according to the market research firm NPD Group. 

These irregularly shaped countertop appliances don't fry food at all. They're actually small convection ovens. A fan circulates hot air to quickly cook food in the basket from the outside in. Finger food you'd typically fry can go in an air fryer instead. Fries, certainly, but add to the list chicken wings, chicken nuggets, jalapeño poppers, cheese sticks, even pizza bites. You get the idea. Most have small capacities, from 2 to 5.8 quarts (often smaller than claimed, according to our measurements).

In the lab, all 25 models in our air fryer ratings turned out nicely cooked food, though staffers who sampled the results weren't fooled into thinking they were deep-fried. "You can tell the difference," says Larry Ciufo, a Consumer Reports test engineer.

Instructions for cooking times and temperatures vary by manufacturer, and though we found minor differences in browning, staffers didn't notice any real differences in taste. "Even when we held cooking times and temperatures constant, the results were very similar, with no discernible differences in taste," says Ciufo. "The real difference among air fryers comes down to convenience, so we designed our tests around that."

We evaluate capacity, how easy the controls are to read and use, noise levels, and how much elbow grease it takes to clean a model.

Here's a roundup of the six best air fryers from CR's tests, listed alphabetically (not by rank order). 

Tip: Don't overload an air fryer's basket. It can slow down cooking and keep air from reaching all of the food, giving you uneven results. And nobody likes soggy fries.

Go to Consumer Reports’ 2019 Holiday Gift Guide for updates on deals, expert product reviews, insider shopping tips, and much more.

Elite Platinum EAF-1506D 3.5 Qt Digital
Elite Platinum EAF-1506D 3.5 Qt...

    Elite Platinum EAF-1506D 3.5 Qt...

    CR's take: The shape of the Elite Platinum EAF-1506D air fryer makes it seem bigger than it is; its measured capacity is 3.4 quarts. But the handle folds down, making it easier to store. The controls and preprogrammed settings are fairly easy to read, and cleaning the inside and outside of the air fryer is easy. But cleaning the basket takes a little doing, knocking its cleaning rating from Excellent down to Very Good. It's relatively quiet, and the warranty is for one year. 

    Farberware HF-919B
    Farberware HF-919B

      Farberware HF-919B

      CR’s take: Its relatively good price and performance make the Farberware HF-919B air fryer a CR Best Buy. It’s among the quietest of the models we’ve tested, earning an Excellent rating in our noise tests. (You can actually hear the mechanical timer ticking over the fan noise.) The dials are fairly easy to read and use, but the nooks and crannies of the food basket make it tough to clean. The basket’s measured capacity is 3.2 quarts. The two-year warranty is longer than most of the models we tested.

      GoWISE GW22731
      GoWISE GW22731

        GoWISE GW22731

        CR’s take: Another CR Best Buy, the GoWise GW22731 has measured capacity of 4.9 quarts. Its touch buttons and programmed settings are among the easiest to see and use, earning an Excellent rating in our assessment. And this is one of the quietest air fryers we tested. The exterior’s crevices and the basket’s nooks and crannies take some effort to clean, however. The warranty is for one year.

        Ninja AF100
        Ninja AF100

          Ninja AF100

          CR's take: Testers found that the 3-quart Ninja AF100's electronic controls with preprogrammed settings were also among the easiest to see and use, earning a rating of Excellent in our assessment of them. Cleaning the inside and outside of this fryer is fairly easy, but it's on the noisy side. The fan is as loud as a countertop microwave, so you'll hear it running. The warranty covers one year.

          NuWave Brio Air Fryer 36011
          NuWave Brio Air Fryer 36011

            NuWave Brio Air Fryer 36011

            CR's take: The NuWave Brio 36011 is a smaller version of the NuWave 37001, and has a measured capacity of just 2.6 quarts, among the smallest we tested. Like the bigger NuWave, the Brio has electronic controls with preprogrammed settings that are among the easiest to see and use of the tested air fryers, earning an Excellent rating. This model isn't as noisy as its sibling, but cleaning the basket is slightly harder. The warranty is for one year.

            NuWave 6-Qt 37001
            NuWave 6-Qt 37001

              NuWave 6-Qt 37001

              CR’s take: The NuWave 37001 air fryer boasts the largest capacity of any model we tested, at 5.8 quarts. Our experts found its electronic controls with preprogrammed settings to be among the easiest to see and use. The inside and outside of the appliance are a cinch to clean, but cleaning food out of the holes in the basket takes a little extra effort. This air fryer is on the noisy side, earning only a Good rating in our noise tests. The fan is as loud as a countertop microwave, so you'll hear it running. The warranty is good for one year.

              For more details and more options, check our air fryer ratings.

              25
              Air Fryers Rated
              Access Ratings
              Kimberly Janeway

              For years I've covered the increasing water and energy efficiency of washers and what it means to consumers, along with innovations in a variety of products, and whether manufacturers deliver on their promises. What I'm really trying to do is to help consumers, and consumers help me by posting comments and posing questions. So thanks!