Top Picks for Cribs in 2025
Meet the three cribs that get our vote for safety, design, and ease of assembly
When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.
Picking out a crib for your littlest family member can feel like a big deal. It needs to be safe, of course, but also sturdy, durable, and easy to put together. And because many cribs are designed to grow with your little one and convert into a toddler bed, a daybed, or even a full-sized bed, it may be a centerpiece of your child’s room well into their toddler and big-kid years, which just adds to the pressure to pick the best one.
CR’s baby product experts test cribs for safety, ease of assembly, and how simple adjusting the mattress height is as a baby grows, along with dozens of other factors. “Our safety testing helps ensure that a crib provides a safe sleep environment for your baby,” says Joan Muratore, who oversees testing of baby products at Consumer Reports.
Top Picks for baby: See more top performers in bassinets, diapers, high chairs, infant car seats, strollers/double strollers, and travel systems.
Muratore uses the federal safety standard for cribs as a blueprint and also checks the integrity of the mattress support, the materials used in construction (including hardware and fasteners), and any defects or inconsistencies in the crib’s finishes.
Her team also assesses:
How easy a crib is to assemble, whether assembly can be managed by one person, and how clear the instructions are. “This can be a pain point when you’re rushing to get your baby’s nursery ready,” Muratore says.
How simple it is to change the mattress height, which you’ll need to do as your baby grows.
Design choices, like how accessible the baby is in the crib, the front rail height, and the type of mattress support used. All of these can affect how functional a crib will be.
Consumer Reports tested 34 cribs from retailers including Babyletto, DaVinci Baby, Ikea, Pottery Barn, and Stokke to find the best. The three models that impressed our testers the most are our Top Picks for cribs for 2025.
CR’s Top Pick for cribs, below, is the highest-rated widely available model from our rigorous lab tests. We’ve also designated a Value Pick that offers a great test score for a good price. And our Expert Pick won top marks for great design, features, and ease of use for a wide range of caregivers.
Top Pick for Cribs: The Pottery Barn Kids Emerson Convertible Crib
Photo: Consumer Reports Photo: Consumer Reports
The Pottery Barn Kids Emerson Convertible Crib has been our highest-rated crib for two years running. This convertible crib “has consistently impressed testers with its remarkable construction quality,” Muratore says. Made of solid pine with a metal mattress support and two height options, it can convert to a toddler bed if you purchase a separate conversion kit. Though it’s not the most cost-conscious model on our list, “its price may be easier to swallow as the crib can be used throughout the toddler years.”
Other features our testers liked include:
• Timeless, rounded spindle design that matches a range of nursery styles.
• Made of kiln-dried wood to ensure there’s no splitting, warping, or cracking.
• Paint is nontoxic and water-based.
• Compatible with a range of Pottery Barn crib mattresses to ensure a snug fit.
Our testers’ Value Pick in cribs for 2025 ranks especially high for ease of assembly and construction while still being cost-conscious. Our Expert Pick is a chic design that our testers liked and that includes a toddler bed conversion kit. Depending on your family’s needs and budget, one of these cribs might be right for you.
