Models lose CR recommendation because of car reliability problems.

Consumer Reports can no longer recommend 12 car models, including the Audi A6, Ford F-150, and Honda Passport, because of problems identified in our annual reliability survey of CR members. 

At the same time, 20 models from Buick, Jeep, Mercedes-Benz, Tesla, and other automakers saw enough improvement in their reported reliability to gain a CR recommendation.

CR gathers reliability data through an online questionnaire sent each year to our members. It asks about any problems the members may have had in the previous 12 months with 17 aspects of their vehicles, including major systems, such as the engine, transmission and electrical system, as well as issues with body hardware and paint and trim. Within each of these potential trouble areas, respondents can give feedback on more specific problems, helping us to understand where a vehicle may have problems. This latest survey has data on 420,000 vehicles as reported by their owners.

More on Car Reliability

To earn a CR recommendation, a car must have a high enough Overall Score within its individual category. The score is calculated using results from CR’s stringent testing, reliability and owner satisfaction surveys, and safety tests. Recommended vehicles must perform well in our testing, have average or better reliability, and perform adequately in crash testing and other safety tests conducted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Not all cars are crash-tested.

“Our reliability scores are especially helpful to car shoppers because we use the extensive feedback from owners to help predict how well your new car will likely hold up,” says Jake Fisher, senior director of auto testing at Consumer Reports. “This way, it can save you from years of frustration when you buy a new model.”

Predicted reliability is a key element in CR’s Overall Score, which is calculated by combining a vehicle’s performance in our road tests; reliability and owner satisfaction ratings drawn from CR’s exclusive Auto Survey; the inclusion of blind spot warning and frontal crash prevention, including systems with pedestrian detection; and, if available, results from government and insurance-industry crash tests.

Newly Recommended Models With Improved Reliability

Our latest predicted-reliability data moved up 20 models in CR’s ratings to the point that they are now recommended. They are the BMW X1, BMW X2, Buick Enclave, Chrysler 300, Dodge Charger, Ford Fusion, Ford Mustang, Honda Clarity, Infiniti QX50, Jeep Grand Cherokee, Kia Cadenza, Lincoln MKZ, Mazda CX-3, Mercedes-Benz E-Class, Mercedes-Benz GLC, Porsche Cayenne, Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model S, Volkswagen GTI, and Volvo XC40.

Models That Lost CR’s Recommendation

In addition to the aforementioned Audi, Ford, and Honda, several manufacturers have models that have seen reliability fall for various reasons. Included below is a description of the problems that owners raised for each, as well as responses, if any, from the manufacturers.

Some of the automakers (Audi, Honda, and Volkswagen) already have either issued technical service bulletins (TSBs) or made updates to deal with some of these problems. TSBs provide dealers with instructions on how to handle a known problem. If you own one of the vehicles with such a bulletin, contact your dealer. Car companies don’t notify owners about these bulletins, so you need to be proactive about getting the fix done.


Audi A6 and A8

Quick Take

2020 Audi A6

Price Range: $54,900 - $73,900

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Quick Take

2020 Audi A8

Price Range: $83,800 - $83,800

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

BMW 3 Series

Quick Take

2020 BMW 3 Series

Price Range: $40,750 - $56,000

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

BMW X5 and X7

Quick Take

2020 BMW X5

Price Range: $58,900 - $114,100

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Quick Take

2020 BMW X7

Price Range: $73,900 - $99,600

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Buick Regal

Quick Take

2020 Buick Regal

Price Range: $25,370 - $39,070

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Ford F-150

Quick Take

2020 Ford F-150

Price Range: $28,495 - $70,910

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Honda Passport

Quick Take

2020 Honda Passport

Price Range: $31,990 - $43,780

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Lincoln Nautilus

Quick Take

2020 Lincoln Nautilus

Price Range: $41,040 - $63,800

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Mercedes-Benz S-Class

Quick Take

2020 Mercedes-Benz S-Class

Price Range: $94,250 - $235,600

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Mini Countryman

Quick Take

2020 Mini Cooper Countryman

Price Range: $28,400 - $41,400

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings

Volkswagen Jetta

Quick Take

2020 Volkswagen Jetta

Price Range: $18,895 - $27,945

View Pricing Information

Reliability
Owner Satisfaction
Unlock Car Ratings