A home office set up with a full-sized desktop computer.

Q. Is there a downside to buying a full-sized desktop instead of an all-in-one model?

A. A full-sized desktop computer, though bulkier than a sleek all-in-one model, can offer similar performance for less money—especially if you already own a monitor.

Even if you do need to buy a new monitor (adding a few hundred dollars to your outlay), your total cost for both the full-sized desktop and monitor may still be lower than for an equivalent all-in-one computer. 


Go to Consumer Reports' 2018 Holiday Central for updates on deals, expert product reviews, insider tips on shopping, and much more.

More on Computers

Compare, say, the cost of the HP Pavilion 595-p0084 full-sized desktop ($750) with the HP 34B010 all-in-one model ($2,000). For more details about what to consider and look for when shopping for a new monitor, check our Computer Monitor Buying Guide.

"Just look for a resolution of at least 1920x1080—regardless of what screen size or brand you prefer," advises Antonette Asedillo, CR's lead computer tester. Full-sized desktops are also easier to upgrade and repair than all-in-one models. Still, for compactness and convenience, an all-in-one is hard to beat.

Editor's Note: This article also appeared in the December 2018 issue of Consumer Reports magazine.