Fisker Karma Vs Porsche Panamera

The four-door Porsche hits the mark, but the Fisker extended-range EV doesn’t

Consumer Reports magazine: November 2012

With sticker prices of more than $100,000 apiece, the Porsche Panamera and Fisker Karma luxury sedans probably aren’t on your shortlist of cars to buy. But each has created a lot of buzz in its own way. Both are four-door, four-passenger cars with eye-catching, coupelike styling. But that’s where the similarity ends.

The Karma is a plug-in, extended-range electric car, similar in concept to the Chevrolet Volt, and is the first car built by the American start-up Fisker. With a full charge, the Karma can go gas-free for about 38 miles, delivering the equivalent of 66 mpg overall (1.96 miles per kilowatt-hour). Once its battery is depleted, a raspy turbocharged gasoline engine kicks in to generate electricity for longer trips. When running on premium gas alone, the Karma gets 22 mpg. Actual fuel economy depends on how often the car runs on electric power. Driving a 50-mile commute on a single full charge yielded the equivalent of 44 mpg overall.

Of course, the sleek, 402-hp Karma is about more than gas mileage. We found its ride, handling, and braking performance to be sound, and interior materials are first-class. But it is plagued with flaws. Compared with other luxury sedans, its tight confines and limited visibility can make the cabin feel claustrophobic; a lack of conventional buttons and the worst touch-screen system we’ve seen make the dash controls an ergonomic disaster; and acceleration lacks the oomph you’d expect from a sports car.

The Karma had a rough start in our testing when it suddenly became disabled on our track. Fisker replaced the battery pack in our car and later offered replacements for all 2012 Karmas. But we’ve continued to encounter disconcerting intermittent glitches related to the gauges, warning lights, power windows, and radio. According to user reviews on the Web, we’re not alone. Overall, the Karma scored too low in our tests to recommend.

The Panamera, Porsche’s first four-door car, was warily received by some sports-car purists when it was introduced in 2009. But we found that our Panamera S, powered by a 400-hp V8, offers an inviting blend of performance and practicality that handily upholds the Porsche pedigree. It delivers quick acceleration and excellent handling. Passengers are coddled in a comfortable, quiet, nicely finished cabin. And a hatchback and folding rear seats add versatility. But the cockpit is somewhat snug, the cluttered controls can be confusing, the firm suspension isn’t as comfortable as that in a traditional luxury sedan, and the low-slung roof makes it challenging to get in or out in a dignified manner. We lack sufficient reliability information to recommend it.


Editor's Note:

A version of this article appeared in the November 2012 issue of Consumer Reports magazine with the headline "Porsche Panamera vs. Fisker Karma."

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters!
Choose from cars, safety, health, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Cars News


Cars Build & Buy Car Buying Service
Save thousands off MSRP with upfront dealer pricing information and a transparent car buying experience.

See your savings


Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more