Inside the labs: Mower differences that matter

Consumer Reports News: July 20, 2010 08:49 AM

With some products, you indeed get what you pay for. But with mowers, price differences of $150 or more may have little to do with how the mower does its most basic job: Cutting grass.

Three self-propelled mowers, all made by Snapper, serve as a good example. We've already tested the Brute BTXPV22700E, $350, and John Deere JS46, $500 ( Ratings available to subscribers.) And we've just purchased the Snapper NXT, $500, for testing.

The models in this trio are alike in several ways. They sport the same 22-inch cutting deck, as you can see in the photo of the Snapper (left) and Brute. Also common to all are the drive system, electric start, and one-lever height adjustment. In tests, the Deere scored a notch higher than the Brute for handling and ease of use.

How they differ is model specific. While all have Briggs & Stratton engines, only on the more costly Snapper and Deere will you find overhead-valve engines. These tend to be more efficient and can last longer if properly maintained. Ergonomics of the handle and drive controls vary. The Snapper's handle sports an LED screen with buttons for six modes: Clock, total hours, trip hours, and timers for changing the oil and replacing the spark plug and air filter. Gimmick? Perhaps, but some of us could use such reminders.

Similarities are common among outdoor power equipment. MTD sells products under its own Cub Cadet, Yard Machines, Yard-Man, Troy-Bilt, and other brands—and also makes some products for Craftsman. Husqvarna products are found under that name as well as Craftsman.

If you want a mower with a few extras, fine, but a less expensive model can also get the job done.

—Ed Perratore

More on mowers: Don't hit the stores before you've checked out our free buying advice for mowers and tractors. Subscribers can view our Ratings for push mowers, self-propelled mowers, and lawn tractors.