2011 Annual Auto Issue: Stuck in reverse

Consumer Reports News: March 14, 2011 10:11 AM

If an automaker pours millions of dollars into a redesign, you expect the new model to be better than the one it replaced. But that's not always true. In the last few years, we've found that several redesigned models scored lower in our tests than their predecessors. Whether because of tightened budgets or new product strategies, it is a disturbing trend, especially because we frequently see declining performance in handling and controls, which can affect vehicle safety.

Some models, such as the Honda Odyssey, Mercedes-Benz E350, and Toyota Sienna, are still very good vehicles that we recommend. But they don't quite measure up to the standards set by their previous generation models. Others, such as the current BMW X5, Toyota 4Runner, and Volkswagen Jetta sedan, are clear disappointments. The models listed below fell the farthest in overall road-test score.

Model	Current score	Previous score	Areas in which test score dropped
Volkswagen Jetta SE (2.5)	60	76	Handling, steering, braking, noise, interior fit and finish
Toyota Sienna FWD/AWD	80/79	93/89	Steering, road noise, interior fit and finish
Toyota 4Runner	55	66	Ride control, handling, noise, driving position, front access, interior fit and finish
BMW X5 3.0	67	77	Controls, shifter, visibility
Mercedes-Benz E350	79	88	Steering, ride, fuel economy
Honda Odyssey	83	91	Handling, braking, cargo area