Worst Coffeemakers Tested

Check our Ratings for machines that make a perfect cup

Published: October 29, 2013 06:00 AM

Find Ratings

Coffeemakers are a popular holiday gift, so if you're looking for a machine for the coffee achiever in your life, check our coffeemaker Ratings. You'll find many low-priced models that hit the mark, including traditional drip, espresso, and pod machines.

But not every coffeemaker we test deliver the convenience and optimal brewing that count, including those featured here.

Michael Graves Design, $115

Flashy with flaws

  • Panasonic NC-ZF1, $230
  • Michael Graves Design (JCPenney), $115
  • Calphalon Quick Brew 1838804, $100

Paying big for the Panasonic drip coffeemaker buys you superb brewing and sturdy construction. but it makes only eight cups at once compared with 12 or 14 for our top picks, and it has a heavy carafe that we found hard to empty. The 12-cup Michael Graves (shown) costs far less and is styled like a 1930s radio but was only so-so in our brewing tests. And Calphalon’s 10-cup Quick Brew was only middling for brewing.

Hamilton Beach BrewStation 49150, $60

Cheap but hardly a bargain

  • Black & Decker CM2020b, $30
  • Proctor Silex 43672, $25
  • Better Chef 91575783M, $20
  • Hamilton Beach BrewStation 49150, $60

The bare-bones Black & Decker and Proctor Silex lost points on brewing, which was just so-so. The Better Chef and Hamilton Beach (shown) did, too. And though the brew-and-dispense Hamilton Beach comes with a syrup dispenser, adding grounds and water requires turning the machine around and working from the back.

Breville You Brew BDC600XL, $280

Lowest scores overall

  • Bunn STX, $135
  • Kitchenaid KCM223CU, $130
  • Bunn Phase Brew HT, $140
  • Breville You Brew BDC600XL, $280

Cumbersome carafes and mediocre brewing put the bunn models and the KitchenAid at the bottom of our scores for conventional drip machines. The grind-and-brew Breville (shown) has a stainless finish, an interactive LCD menu, and other helpful features. It also brewed respectably. But we found it to be a chore to clean compared with others we tested, and its thermal carafe was hard to empty.


Find Ratings

Coffee Makers Ratings

View and compare all Coffee Makers ratings.

Coffee Ratings

View and compare all Coffee ratings.

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters! Choose from cars, safety, health, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Appliances News


Cars Build & Buy Car Buying Service
Save thousands off MSRP with upfront dealer pricing information and a transparent car buying experience.

See your savings


Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more