Product Reviews

Welcome to Consumer Reports.

We’re so glad to have you as a member. You now have access to benefits that can help you choose right, be safe and stay informed.

Shovels that make light work of heavy snow

The trusty old snow shovel gets some innovative upgrades

Published: February 23, 2015 02:00 PM

Find Ratings

Because snow blowers require upkeep and storage space, not every homeowner is interested in owning one. So it's fortunate that manufacturers continue to come up with new variations on snow shovels. Consumer Reports recently tested two innovative shovels—including a beefy option for those who can push snow but not lift it—and we're looking at a third shovel that won't be available until after the snow melts.

Poly Pro Tools Titan

Poly Pro Tools Titan

We bought this all-plastic shovel for $35 at a nearby True Value hardware store. It might not impress you at first, but we found the Titan rigid, heavy, and well suited for even moist, slushy snow.

The wide, D-shaped handle lets you use two hands and your body to direct the shovel beneath packed snow, and the slot at the top of the shovel’s pan lets you grip the shovel closer to the load for when you need some extra oomph. While this forces either deep knee bends or some serious bending, it’s handy for infrequent lifting. Another plus: Because it’s plastic, snow doesn’t stick to it as readily as with an aluminum shovel. We don’t recommend the Titan for light, fluffy snow. But for the heavy stuff, it’s a nice addition to your arsenal.

Nordic Plow Perfect Shovel

Nordic Plow Perfect Shovel

Nordic Plow manufactures snowplows for select models of lawn tractors and zero-turn-radius riders, and the Perfect Shovel looks like a scaled-down version of the plow. It’s not quite a shovel since it’s a push-only tool. Still, the product shows a lot of thought and should work for up to six inches of snow if it's not too compressed.

We found it surprisingly effective, appreciating how it bites into the brittle crust under about four inches of snow, and digs under even car-packed snow. The vertically textured grips are adjustable and comfortable. Another plus is that pulling out two pins lets you rotate the upper, rounded edge to the blade’s bottom—in case you’re clearing a gravel or otherwise uneven surface. We tested the 24-inch model, $150 at Home Depot. There’s also a 36-inch model, but we suspect it would be limited to only a couple of inches of snow since there’d be 50 percent more to push.

The other shovel we’re testing, the Snow/Scoop Shovel from Bosse Tools, won’t be at retailers until the spring. The $80 model has a circular, swiveling handle halfway down the shovel’s shaft. We’ll let you know how it does in our tests, confident that you’ll still have snow on your mind—if not in your driveway.

Ariens 921032

Prefer a new snow blower?

Normally at this time of year, snow blowers are gone from store inventories, but the number of snowstorms across much of the country has all but guaranteed that many retailers have restocked. If you're shopping for one, be sure to check out our snow blower buying guide before checking our Ratings of more than 110 snow blowers. Among top-scoring gas models are the two-stage, 30-inch Cub Cadet 31AH57S, $1,500, and Ariens 921032, $1,300, the compact, 24-inch two-stage Craftsman 88173, $680, and the single-stage, 21-inch Toro Power Clear 721E, $570.

—Ed Perratore (@EdPerratore on Twitter)

Find Ratings

Snow Blowers Ratings

View and compare all Snow Blowers ratings.

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters! Choose from cars, safety, health, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Home & Garden News


Cars Build & Buy Car Buying Service
Save thousands off MSRP with upfront dealer pricing information and a transparent car buying experience.

See your savings


Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more