Your Car Is Sharing Data With Big Tech Companies, Study Finds
Data sent by vehicles and companion apps included locations, VINs, and other identifiers. Amazon, Google, Meta, and Microsoft were among the top receivers of driver data.
Your car may be spying on you—and transmitting what it learns to some of the world’s biggest tech companies.
That’s the core finding of a series of tests conducted by privacy researchers at Northeastern University in Boston, using Consumer Reports’ vehicles and Auto Test Center in Connecticut. A study about the results will be published this week.
It has been known for some time that many late-model automobiles collect detailed data about our driving and share it with companies that may use it for marketing purposes and even to individualize insurance premiums or auto loan rates. Regulators have reprimanded and fined automakers for allegedly failing to clearly disclose this practice, and several automakers have been sued for it.
The new Northeastern study shows, for the first time, data flowing among the vehicles, the vehicle apps you download when you buy your car, and third-party companies, documenting exactly what kind of data gets siphoned from our vehicles and which companies are receiving that information.
Three Ways Researchers Measured How Much Data Cars Transmit
A team of privacy experts from Northeastern university spent time at CR's Connecticut text facility intercepting network traffic from 21 vehicles and 30 automaker mobile apps.
-
WiFi interception: WiFi traffic was captured while vehicles were stationary and while being driven at moderate speeds, and with bursts of rapid acceleration, hard braking, and swerving meant to simulate reckless driving.
-
Faraday tent: Data was captured with vehicles placed in an electromagnetic wave-blocking Faraday tent in order to block cellular signals from the vehicles and isolate their WiFi signals.
-
App traffic: Once logged in, testers used all app functionality, including geolocating the car, checking its service history, and, when possible, opening the trunk.
Of the vehicles tested, 28 of 30 connected mobile apps sent data to at least one outside advertising and/or analytics company, and seven sent at least one piece of personally identifiable information—the vehicle owner’s name, the car’s VIN, or its precise geographic location—to at least one outside company.
Four GM companion apps—myCadillac, myChevrolet, myBuick, and myGMC—as well as the HondaLink, MyNissan, and Lincoln apps, were found to be sharing VINs paired with either email addresses or location data.
The top recipients of driver data included many of the largest tech companies operating in the U.S., including Alphabet (which runs Google), Amazon, Meta (which runs Facebook), Microsoft, Pinterest, and Reddit, among dozens of others. Many of these companies play two roles in the driver data ecosystem, as both providers of software (such as the Android Automotive operating system) and as operators of advertising “auction” platforms that marketers use to target specific types of customers. As such, the companies that collect driver data are often the first node in a vast personal data ecosystem.
The vehicles that sent data to the largest number of outside advertising and analytics companies were the Cadillac Lyriq, Chevrolet Blazer, Lucid Air, and Tesla Model 3 and Cybertruck. Connected mobile apps from BMW, General Motors brands (including Buick, Cadillac, and GMC), and Toyota contacted the largest number of outside companies.
The findings underscore the immense personal data ecosystem that American consumers are unwittingly drawn into when they purchase and use everyday consumer products, including autos.
The most worrisome privacy finding, the researchers say, is that some of the vehicles and their connected mobile apps shared both a VIN and another identifier, such as the vehicle owner’s name or email address. With those two pieces of info, a major advertising or technology company can link the owner to one of many commercially available consumer profiles, which are sold by data brokers and other companies. The data often includes online behavior and shopping history.
Here’s some advice that may enable you to opt out of sharing and delete your driver behavior data.
Photos: John Powers/Consumer Reports Photos: John Powers/Consumer Reports