The Best Shower Caddy Is One That Stays Put

I evaluated six hanging shower caddies over the course of a month and a half in my small stall shower. I looked at how easy they were to install, how well they fit my husband’s and my shower products, and how well those items stayed in place. I also looked at whether any of the caddies discolored over time. We did not look at the basket-style caddie—think transporting essentials in a dorm with a communal bathroom.

Despite the simplicity of these products, one shined as the clear winner.