Everything You Need to Host a Winning Super Bowl Party
Top air fryers, toaster ovens, and more kitchen tools to help you prep, plus great deals on top TVs
When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.
You can’t control the players, the referees, or the weather on Super Bowl Sunday. But you can throw a great Super Bowl party for yourself and your fellow fans on Feb. 9, when the Kansas City Chiefs take on the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LIX. From TVs that let you see every detail on the field to small appliances that will help you serve up tasty snacks, check out these top-performing products from CR’s tests.
Food-Prep and Storage Essentials
Make preparty food prep a snap with a trusty set of storage containers. Instant Brands’ versatile set of glass containers achieved top scores in our tests for storage, seal quality, durability, and ease of use. You’ll find containers round, rectangular, and square in capacities that are small, medium, and big (specifically, 8-ounce, 16-ounce, and 32-ounce). So there are plenty of options, whether you’re packing up soup for one or a batch of chili for tailgating. The plastic lids feature snap-and-lock flaps and a rubber gasket, though the gasket isn’t removable. With this many storage options at a low price, you’ll never find yourself trying to squeeze a lid shut on a too-full container again.
For more options: Best Food Storage Containers
The Meater Plus is a darling of the barbecue world, and it’s easy to see why. For starters, it has exceptionally robust alarm settings. It will ping you when your food is ready and also let you know if the ambient air temperature of your grill drops too low. (This comes in handy when you need to adjust your dampers or add more charcoal.) The app also chimes again when resting time is complete.
For more options: Best Smart Meat Thermometers
If you’ve been thinking about hopping on the air fryer trend, the big game may just be the time. The Dash Digital Tasti Crisp is small but mighty. At a measured capacity of 1.9 quarts and an overall size of less than a square foot, this 6-pound model is one of the most compact air fryers in our ratings. Still, it ranks among the best. It earns strong scores for controls and cleaning, and excels in our noise test. It has a one-year warranty, which is typical for air fryers.
For more options: Best Air Fryers
The Great Jones cookware line puts a vibrant spin on culinary staples, turning the stocking of a kitchen into a—dare we say—fun experience. It earns a very good rating for cooking evenness in our tests, plus it heats up quickly and cleans up nicely. Pair it with all the necessary ingredients for chocolate chip cookies or a sheet pan dinner and you’ll be golden.
For more options: Best Sheet Pans
Whether you’re toasting up a batch of your nana’s famous chili cheese puffs or reheating snacks later, a trusty toaster oven can be quite the kitchen workhouse. With a temperature range of 120° F to 450° F, the 1,800-watt Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL does a nice job of baking food, reheating leftovers, and turning out a batch of even, medium-brown toast. More praise: It’s a cinch to operate and easy to clean. Plus, CR members gave the brand high praise for reliability and owner satisfaction in our most recent survey.
For more options: Best Toaster Ovens
Get that game-day chili just right with the Breville Fast Slow Pro 6 qt. BPR700BSS Multi-Cooker. It has a pressure-cook mode and aces our test of that function. It’s also one of the best at slow-cooking, earning top marks. Our beef stew turned out tender and ready to eat in 5 hours, and the chili was tender and delicious in 7 hours. Steaming is top-notch because this 1,100-watt cooker doesn’t use pressure for that mode. (Unlike other models, the lid on this Breville doesn’t lock during steaming, so you can monitor your broccoli’s shade of green and avoid overcooking.) The ceramic nonstick coating is a cinch to clean and didn’t show any scratches after testing.
For more options: Best Multi-Cookers
Tia Mowry’s celeb cookware line is called Spice, and the color of this one is saffron. Now you can serve rice the same hue as the pan you cooked it in! But that’s not the main reason we like this pan. It heats up quickly and bakes bread with a crispy crust, earning the highest score possible on both tests. It’s almost as good at simmering sauces and heats evenly. Best of all, it’s a cinch to clean. It weighs almost 14 pounds and has a cooking surface that’s 8 inches in diameter.
For more options: Best Dutch Ovens
Perhaps you don’t have time for chopping, slicing, and dicing the multiple toppings that adorn your legendary nachos. Enter the food processor. The Cuisinart Custom 14 DFP-14BCNY garners top marks for chopping, meaning it consistently chopped onions and nuts into midsized pieces. And it’s one of the quietest models we’ve tested. It has a 14-cup capacity and stands almost 16 inches high. Many of the food processors we’ve evaluated operate with touch buttons, but this one has levers—one for on, the other for pulsing and off. The warranty covers three years, five for the motor. It’s available in brushed stainless, copper, and stainless mixed with black or white.
The Ninja Master Prep Professional QB1004 chopper has a slightly smaller 2.5-cup capacity but is still very versatile. Included in this set are a larger 5-cup processing bowl and a 6-cup blender jar. The chopper features a top-mounted motor that you push down to operate. It earns impressive scores for chopping and turning out nicely chopped veggies and nuts in our tests.
For more options: Best Food Processors and Choppers
Kitchenware
Fredericks & Mae Small Cutting Board
There’s something to be said about splurging on the basics with the intention of elevating the everyday. Case in point: This speckled plastic cutting board can easily transition from a prep station to the dinner table. Its eye-catching composition, with the bright yellow handle, is just one reason to love it—it also happens to be quite sturdy and available in a variety of equally fun colorways.
Certified International Talavera 12-Piece Melamine Dinnerware Set
Serve up snacks with some pizazz with these melamine dishes. This 12-piece set’s beautiful, medium-weight plates and bowls are ideal for almost any situation that might require unbreakable plates, from Super Bowl parties to dining alfresco. Our at-home testers found them neither especially heavy nor flimsy. They sit evenly, have a smooth, unblemished glaze, and aren’t scratched by knives and forks. They made a loud clatter when dropped but didn’t break.
Oster Electric Wine Opener and Foil Cutter Kit
For anyone who has ever struggled to open a bottle of wine with a waiter’s corkscrew (present company included), here’s one item that will be useful for "I almost exclusively drink wine at home and love this electric wine opener for opening bottles," says CR writer Jodhaira Rodriguez. "I struggled to get the cork out of bottles with a manual corkscrew for a very long time before my dad introduced me to the world of electric wine openers. This was a game changer for me."
Standout Snacks & Condiments
Frozen Pizza
Red Baron Classic Crust Four-Cheese Pizza
Not everyone wants or needs to cook for a party, which is exactly why frozen pizza exists. In our recent evaluation, this Red Baron pie was a crowd-pleaser, with a balance of flavors and textures that are just right. You get the distinct taste of crust, sauce, and cheese in each bite. “Overall, this one exceeded my expectations,” said Lauren Friedman, who heads up CR’s health and food team. As it says on the box, the crust isn’t too thick or too thin. The sauce is the standout here. “It’s very peppery and gives the whole pizza a more well-rounded and interesting taste.”
For more options: Best Frozen Pizzas
Beef Hot Dog
Nathan's Famous Skinless Beef Franks
The original. The best. The pinnacle of hot dogs. This one comes from one of the oldest hot dog companies in the U.S. Its founder, Nathan Handwerker, was a Polish immigrant who worked at a Coney Island hot dog stand until he was able to scrounge up enough money to open his own business in 1916. That full century of expertise is evident in this hot dog, which one evaluator, Paul Hope, a Consumer Reports home and appliance reporter and food writer, called “the Goldilocks of hot dogs: crisp skin, subtle spice, uniform texture, and juicy.”
For more options: Best Hot Dogs
Vegan Sausage
Beyond Meat Bratwurst
These bratwursts are spectacular: juicy and garlicky, with a tiny bit of sweetness that’s balanced by a rich savoriness that places them firmly in the lunch or dinner category. (Despite that hint of sweetness, they don’t taste like your traditional breakfast sausage.) This sausage is “rich and aromatic, with notes of fennel and a deep umami flavor,” says Paul Hope, a CR food writer. “They clearly worked on this formula and it shows!”
For more options: Best Vegan Hot Dogs and Sausages
Fly by Jing Triple Threat Sauce Trio
Miguel Leal is a big fan of Fly by Jing. The co-founder of Somos—a purveyor of ready-to-eat Mexican foods—recommends the Triple Threat gift set for home cooks who want to get creative in the kitchen. “It contains three products, one of which is the Sichuan Chili Crisp, which is a super-versatile sauce that I use on everything from eggs to dumplings and rice, and even on sushi,” Leal says. “It has a great level of spicy—but isn’t too spicy!—and I love the texture it adds to my food.”
Crowd-Pleasing Beverages
Mocktail
Hella Cocktail Co. Spritz Aromatic Bitters & Soda
This drink is hella intense. It’s a gorgeous ruby red, and the taste is like a rave in your mouth: vivid, overpowering, bitter, sweet. Like several other nonalcoholic cocktails we tried, it’s flavored with clove, allspice, and star anise, though this one has a heavy dose of sugar, making it one of the sweetest sparklers in the bunch. On its own, it’s a bit much. But mixed with alcohol, it works, though it does defeat the purpose of a nonalcoholic cocktail. Though we haven’t tried it ourselves, it’s possible this would be equally delicious with nonalcoholic bourbon or gin as with the real stuff. You could also just add sparkling water to tone things down.
For more options: Best Ready-to-Drink Mocktails
Canned Spirits
Cutwater Tequila Paloma
Our CR evaluators dubbed Cutwater’s Tequila Paloma “the party pick” in a recent evaluation of canned cocktails. It’s a mild—if faithful—version of a bar paloma that’s refreshing, lightly citrusy, and not unbearably sweet. It’s a great option for parties because the price is reasonable, it’s widely available, and it’s almost impossible not to like. This also means it won’t really stand out; you drink it to chill out and have fun with friends, not to contemplate the subtle hints of black pepper and agave from the brand’s proprietary tequila, which is used in this cocktail. Buy this instead of the hard seltzer you usually get for your house parties.
For more options: Best Canned Cocktails
TVs on Sale
Although a 2023 set, the LG OLED77C3PUA is a top-performing OLED that’s worth owning, and thanks to more than a year of price drops it’s a lower, though still not inexpensive, price. It aced our picture quality tests, has great sound, and very good HDR performance. We saw this set for about $100 less at Best Buy during Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, but every other major retailer never sold it for under $2,000—Amazon and Walmart now list it at full retail value for around $1,800.
Unlike some other Onn TVs we’ve tested, which have done fairly well for overall picture quality, the 65-inch Onn 100012587 from Walmart’s private label brand does only okay in our tests and worse than that for HDR. Still, this is a very low price for a 4K set this size and might be an option for less finicky viewers on a tight budget. It’s a Roku TV, so it has access to a lot of streaming services. It matches the price we saw on Cyber Monday.
The TCL 55Q550F, which uses the Amazon Fire TV smart system, is an entry-level QLED TV from 2023 that does well for 4K picture quality in our tests, though not as well for HD or HDR performance. Right now we see this set, which has the Alexa voice assistant built in, only at Best Buy. Note that it’s now $20 more than on Cyber Monday.
For more TV discounts: Best Super Bowl TV Deals
Get discounts, product recommendations, and buying advice from the shopping experts at CR. Sign up for our ShopSmart newsletter.