Product Reviews

Welcome to Consumer Reports.

We’re so glad to have you as a member. You now have access to benefits that can help you choose right, be safe and stay informed.

Butter Pat Joan Cast Iron Skillet cookware

This Butter Pat frypan is 12 -inches

  • weighs 6.3 lbs. and is
  • oven safe.
  • Also, can be used on a campfire.
  • Cooking evenness was very good.


The Butter Pat Joan Cast Iron Skillet is part of the Cookware test program at Consumer Reports. In our lab tests, Cookware models like the Joan Cast Iron Skillet are rated on multiple criteria, such as those listed below.

Pan size: Pan size, in inches, per manufacturer.

Baking: We made cornbread in the frypan which gives an indication of how well the frypan can bake. We looked at moistness and how evenly golden brown the cornbread was on both the top and the bottom.

Browning: How evenly the fry pan can brown foods. Those scoring Excellent browned food evenly; those scoring Poor did not brown foods evenly.


Oven-safe Oven-safe Based on manufacturers' information; the skillet is oven safe
Warranty Warranty The length of time the frypan is covered by its manufacturer for defects or repairs.
100 yr
Pouring spout Pouring spout If the frypan has a pouring spout or not.
Campfire use Campfire use If the cast iron frypan be used on an open campfire.


Weight Weight The weight of the skillet empty.
Interior cooking surface (in.) Interior cooking surface The diameter of the interior cooking surface.
Interior height (in.) Interior height The height of the interior of the cast iron frypan.
Handle temperature (°F) Handle temperature This is an average temperature taken while cooking at both low and high temperatures.
Handle length (in.) Handle length The length of the handle in inches.
Cleaning Cleaning How the manufacturer wants the consumer to clean the skillet.
After each use, when slightly warm, scrape out food residue and rinse with hot water. Stubborn residue, use a touch of dish soap and green scrubber. Towel dry and put back on stove at medium heat to completely dry the frypan. Put cooking oil in pan, spread with towel and wait until it cools to wipe out excess.